text:
Clifford algebra

In mathematics, a Clifford algebra is an algebra generated by a vector space with a quadratic form, and is a unital associative algebra with the additional structure of a distinguished subspace. As $K$-algebras, they generalize the real numbers, complex numbers, quaternions and several other hypercomplex number systems. The theory of Clifford algebras is intimately connected with the theory of quadratic forms and orthogonal transformations. Clifford algebras have important applications in a variety of fields including geometry, theoretical physics and digital image processing. They are named after the English mathematician William Kingdon Clifford (1845–1879).

The most familiar Clifford algebras, the orthogonal Clifford algebras, are also referred to as (pseudo-)Riemannian Clifford algebras, as distinct from symplectic Clifford algebras.

Introduction and basic properties
A Clifford algebra is a unital associative algebra that contains and is generated by a vector space $V$ over a field $K$, where $V$ is equipped with a quadratic form $Q : V → K$. The Clifford algebra $Cl(V, Q)$ is the "freest" unital associative algebra generated by $V$ subject to the condition $$v^2 = Q(v)1\ \text{ for all } v\in V,$$ where the product on the left is that of the algebra, and the $v^{2} = −Q(v)$ is its multiplicative identity. The idea of being the "freest" or "most general" algebra subject to this identity can be formally expressed through the notion of a universal property, as done below.

When $Q$ is a finite-dimensional real vector space and $−Q$ is nondegenerate, $1$ may be identified by the label $V$, indicating that $Q$ has an orthogonal basis with $Cl(V, Q)$ elements with $Cl_{p,q}(R)$, $V$ with $p$, and where $e_{i}^{2} = +1$ indicates that this is a Clifford algebra over the reals; i.e. coefficients of elements of the algebra are real numbers. This basis may be found by orthogonal diagonalization.

The free algebra generated by $q$ may be written as the tensor algebra $e_{i}^{2} = −1$, that is, the direct sum of the tensor product of $R$ copies of $V$ over all $⨁_{n≥0} V ⊗ ⋯ ⊗ V$. Therefore one obtains a Clifford algebra as the quotient of this tensor algebra by the two-sided ideal generated by elements of the form $n$ for all elements $V$. The product induced by the tensor product in the quotient algebra is written using juxtaposition (e.g. $n$). Its associativity follows from the associativity of the tensor product.

The Clifford algebra has a distinguished subspace $v ⊗ v − Q(v)1$, being the image of the embedding map. Such a subspace cannot in general be uniquely determined given only a $v ∈ V$-algebra that is isomorphic to the Clifford algebra.

If $uv$ is invertible in the ground field $V$, then one can rewrite the fundamental identity above in the form $$uv + vu = 2\langle u, v\rangle1\ \text{ for all } u,v \in V,$$ where $$\langle u, v \rangle = \frac{1}{2} \left( Q(u + v) - Q(u) - Q(v) \right)$$ is the symmetric bilinear form associated with $K$, via the polarization identity.

Quadratic forms and Clifford algebras in characteristic $2$ form an exceptional case in this respect. In particular, if $K$ it is not true that a quadratic form necessarily or uniquely determines a symmetric bilinear form that satisfies $Q$, Many of the statements in this article include the condition that the characteristic is not $2$, and are false if this condition is removed.

As a quantization of the exterior algebra
Clifford algebras are closely related to exterior algebras. Indeed, if $char(K) = 2$ then the Clifford algebra $Q(v) =$ is just the exterior algebra $2$. Whenever $Q = 0$ is invertible in the ground field $Cl(V, Q)$, there exists a canonical linear isomorphism between $⋀V$ and $2$. That is, they are naturally isomorphic as vector spaces, but with different multiplications (in the case of characteristic two, they are still isomorphic as vector spaces, just not naturally). Clifford multiplication together with the distinguished subspace is strictly richer than the exterior product since it makes use of the extra information provided by $K$.

The Clifford algebra is a filtered algebra; the associated graded algebra is the exterior algebra.

More precisely, Clifford algebras may be thought of as quantizations (cf. quantum group) of the exterior algebra, in the same way that the Weyl algebra is a quantization of the symmetric algebra.

Weyl algebras and Clifford algebras admit a further structure of a *-algebra, and can be unified as even and odd terms of a superalgebra, as discussed in CCR and CAR algebras.

Universal property and construction
Let $⋀V$ be a vector space over a field $Cl(V, Q)$, and let $Q$ be a quadratic form on $V$. In most cases of interest the field $K$ is either the field of real numbers $Q : V → K$, or the field of complex numbers $V$, or a finite field.

A Clifford algebra $K$ is a pair $R$, where $C$ is a unital associative algebra over $Cl(V, Q)$ and $(B, i)$ is a linear map $i$ that satisfies $γ$ for all $(A, γ)$ in $(V, g)$, defined by the following universal property: given any unital associative algebra $A$ over $\{ γ(v)$ and any linear map $\{ a1A$ such that $$j(v)^2 = Q(v)1_A \text{ for all } v \in V$$ (where $γ$ denotes the multiplicative identity of $γ(v)γ(u) + γ(u)γ(v) = 2g(v, u)$), there is a unique algebra homomorphism $v, u ∈ V$ such that the following diagram commutes (i.e. such that $B$):

The quadratic form $K$ may be replaced by a (not necessarily symmetric) bilinear form $i$ that has the property $i : V → B$, in which case an equivalent requirement on $i(v)^{2} = Q(v)1B$ is $$ j(v)j(v) = \langle v, v \rangle 1_A \quad \text{ for all } v \in V .$$

When the characteristic of the field is not $v$, this may be replaced by what is then an equivalent requirement, $$ j(v)j(w) + j(w)j(v) = ( \langle v, w \rangle + \langle w, v \rangle )1_A \quad \text{ for all } v, w \in V, $$ where the bilinear form may additionally be restricted to being symmetric without loss of generality.

A Clifford algebra as described above always exists and can be constructed as follows: start with the most general algebra that contains $V$, namely the tensor algebra $A$, and then enforce the fundamental identity by taking a suitable quotient. In our case we want to take the two-sided ideal $K$ in $j : V → A$ generated by all elements of the form $$v\otimes v - Q(v)1$$ for all $$v\in V$$ and define $1_{A}$ as the quotient algebra $$\operatorname{Cl}(V, Q) = T(V) / I_Q .$$

The ring product inherited by this quotient is sometimes referred to as the Clifford product to distinguish it from the exterior product and the scalar product.

It is then straightforward to show that $A$ contains $f : B → A$ and satisfies the above universal property, so that $f ∘ i = j$ is unique up to a unique isomorphism; thus one speaks of "the" Clifford algebra $Q$. It also follows from this construction that $$ is injective. One usually drops the $= Q(v), v ∈ V$ and considers $j$ as a linear subspace of $2$.

The universal characterization of the Clifford algebra shows that the construction of $V$ is in nature. Namely, $T(V)$ can be considered as a functor from the category of vector spaces with quadratic forms (whose morphisms are linear maps that preserve the quadratic form) to the category of associative algebras. The universal property guarantees that linear maps between vector spaces (that preserve the quadratic form) extend uniquely to algebra homomorphisms between the associated Clifford algebras.

Basis and dimension
Since $I_{Q}$ comes equipped with a quadratic form $T(V)$, in characteristic not equal to $Cl(V, Q)$ there exist bases for $Cl(V, Q)$ that are orthogonal. An orthogonal basis is one such that for a symmetric bilinear form $$\langle e_i, e_j \rangle = 0 $$ for $$ i\neq j$$, and $$\langle e_i, e_i \rangle = Q(e_i).$$

The fundamental Clifford identity implies that for an orthogonal basis $$e_i e_j = -e_j e_i$$ for $$i \neq j$$, and $$e_i^2 = Q(e_i).$$

This makes manipulation of orthogonal basis vectors quite simple. Given a product $$e_{i_1}e_{i_2}\cdots e_{i_k}$$ of distinct orthogonal basis vectors of $V$, one can put them into a standard order while including an overall sign determined by the number of pairwise swaps needed to do so (i.e. the signature of the ordering permutation).

If the dimension of $Cl$ over $Cl(V, Q)$ is $i$ and $i$ is an orthogonal basis of $V$, then $Cl(V, Q)$ is free over $Cl(V, Q)$ with a basis $$\{e_{i_1}e_{i_2}\cdots e_{i_k} \mid 1\le i_1 < i_2 < \cdots < i_k \le n\text{ and } 0\le k\le n\}.$$

The empty product ($Cl$) is defined as being the multiplicative identity element. For each value of $V$ there are $Q$ basis elements, so the total dimension of the Clifford algebra is $$\dim \operatorname{Cl}(V, Q) = \sum_{k=0}^n \binom{n}{k} = 2^n.$$

Examples: real and complex Clifford algebras
The most important Clifford algebras are those over real and complex vector spaces equipped with nondegenerate quadratic forms.

Each of the algebras $2$ and $V$ is isomorphic to $V$ or $V$, where $K$ is a full matrix ring with entries from $n$, $\{e_{1}, ..., e_{n}\}$, or $(V, Q)$. For a complete classification of these algebras see Classification of Clifford algebras.

Real numbers
Clifford algebras are also sometimes referred to as geometric algebras, most often over the real numbers.

Every nondegenerate quadratic form on a finite-dimensional real vector space is equivalent to the standard diagonal form: $$Q(v) = v_1^2 + \dots + v_p^2 - v_{p+1}^2 - \dots - v_{p+q}^2 ,$$ where $Cl(V, Q)$ is the dimension of the vector space. The pair of integers $K$ is called the signature of the quadratic form. The real vector space with this quadratic form is often denoted $k = 0$ The Clifford algebra on $k$ is denoted $n choose k$ The symbol $Clp,q(R)$  means either $Cln(C)$ or $A$, depending on whether the author prefers positive-definite or negative-definite spaces.

A standard basis $A ⊕ A$ for $A$ consists of $R$ mutually orthogonal vectors, $C$ of which square to $H$ and $n = p + q$ of which square to $(p, q)$. Of such a basis, the algebra $R^{p,q}.$ will therefore have $Rp,q$ vectors that square to $Clp,q(R).$ and $Cln(R)$ vectors that square to $Cln,0(R)$.

A few low-dimensional cases are:
 * $Cl0,n(R)$ is naturally isomorphic to ${e_{1}, ..., e_{n}} |undefined$ since there are no nonzero vectors.
 * $R^{p,q}$ is a two-dimensional algebra generated by $n = p + q$ that squares to $p$, and is algebra-isomorphic to $+1$, the field of complex numbers.
 * $q$ is a four-dimensional algebra spanned by $−1$. The latter three elements all square to $Clp,q(R)$ and anticommute, and so the algebra is isomorphic to the quaternions $p$.
 * $+1$ is an 8-dimensional algebra isomorphic to the direct sum $q$, the split-biquaternions.

Complex numbers
One can also study Clifford algebras on complex vector spaces. Every nondegenerate quadratic form on a complex vector space of dimension $−1$ is equivalent to the standard diagonal form $$Q(z) = z_1^2 + z_2^2 + \dots + z_n^2.$$ Thus, for each dimension $Cl0,0(R)$, up to isomorphism there is only one Clifford algebra of a complex vector space with a nondegenerate quadratic form. We will denote the Clifford algebra on $R$ with the standard quadratic form by $Cl0,1(R)$.

For the first few cases one finds that where $e_{1}$ denotes the algebra of $−1$ matrices over $C$.
 * $Cl0,2(R)$, the complex numbers
 * $\{1, e_{1}, e_{2}, e_{1}e_{2}\}$, the bicomplex numbers
 * $−1$, the biquaternions

Quaternions
In this section, Hamilton's quaternions are constructed as the even subalgebra of the Clifford algebra $H$.

Let the vector space $Cl0,3(R)$ be real three-dimensional space $H ⊕ H$, and the quadratic form be the usual quadratic form. Then, for $n$ in $n$ we have the bilinear form (or scalar product) $$v \cdot w = v_1 w_1 + v_2 w_2 + v_3 w_3.$$ Now introduce the Clifford product of vectors $C^{n}$ and $Cln(C)$ given by $$ v w + w v = 2 (v \cdot w) .$$

Denote a set of orthogonal unit vectors of $Cl0(C) ≅ C$ as $Cl1(C) ≅ C ⊕ C$, then the Clifford product yields the relations $$ e_2 e_3 = -e_3 e_2, \,\,\, e_1 e_3 = -e_3 e_1,\,\,\,  e_1 e_2 = -e_2 e_1,$$ and $$ e_1 ^2 = e_2^2 = e_3^2 = 1. $$ The general element of the Clifford algebra $Cl2(C) ≅ M_{2}(C)$ is given by $$ A = a_0 + a_1 e_1 + a_2 e_2 + a_3 e_3 + a_4 e_2 e_3 + a_5 e_1 e_3 + a_6 e_1 e_2 + a_7 e_1 e_2 e_3.$$

The linear combination of the even degree elements of $M_{n}(C)$ defines the even subalgebra $n × n$ with the general element $$ q = q_0 + q_1 e_2 e_3 + q_2 e_1 e_3 + q_3 e_1 e_2. $$ The basis elements can be identified with the quaternion basis elements $C$ as $$ i= e_2 e_3, j =  e_1 e_3, k =  e_1 e_2,$$ which shows that the even subalgebra $Cl3,0(R)$ is Hamilton's real quaternion algebra.

To see this, compute $$ i^2 = (e_2 e_3)^2 = e_2 e_3 e_2 e_3 = - e_2 e_2 e_3 e_3 = -1,$$ and $$ ij = e_2 e_3 e_1 e_3 = -e_2 e_3 e_3 e_1 = -e_2 e_1 = e_1 e_2 = k.$$ Finally, $$ ijk = e_2 e_3 e_1 e_3 e_1 e_2 = -1.$$

Dual quaternions
In this section, dual quaternions are constructed as the even subalgebra of a Clifford algebra of real four-dimensional space with a degenerate quadratic form.

Let the vector space $V$ be real four-dimensional space $R^{3}$ and let the quadratic form $v, w$ be a degenerate form derived from the Euclidean metric on $R^{3}$ For $v$ in $w$ introduce the degenerate bilinear form $$d(v, w) = v_1 w_1 + v_2 w_2 + v_3 w_3 .$$ This degenerate scalar product projects distance measurements in $R^{3}$ onto the $\{e_{1}, e_{2}, e_{3}\}$ hyperplane.

The Clifford product of vectors $Cl3,0(R)$ and $Cl3,0(R)$ is given by $$v w + w v = -2 \,d(v, w).$$ Note the negative sign is introduced to simplify the correspondence with quaternions.

Denote a set of mutually orthogonal unit vectors of $Cl[0] 3,0(R)$ as $i, j, k$, then the Clifford product yields the relations $$e_m e_n = -e_n e_m, \,\,\, m \ne n,$$ and $$e_1 ^2 = e_2^2 = e_3^2 = -1, \,\, e_4^2 = 0.$$

The general element of the Clifford algebra $Cl[0] 3,0(R)$ has 16 components. The linear combination of the even degree elements defines the even subalgebra $V$ with the general element $$ H = h_0 + h_1 e_2 e_3 + h_2 e_3 e_1 + h_3 e_1 e_2 + h_4 e_4 e_1 + h_5 e_4 e_2 + h_6 e_4 e_3 + h_7 e_1 e_2 e_3 e_4.$$

The basis elements can be identified with the quaternion basis elements $R^{4},$ and the dual unit $Q$ as $$ i = e_2 e_3, j = e_3 e_1, k = e_1 e_2, \,\, \varepsilon = e_1 e_2 e_3 e_4.$$ This provides the correspondence of $R^{3}.$ with dual quaternion algebra.

To see this, compute $$ \varepsilon ^2 = (e_1 e_2 e_3 e_4)^2 = e_1 e_2 e_3 e_4 e_1 e_2 e_3 e_4 = -e_1 e_2 e_3 (e_4 e_4 ) e_1 e_2 e_3 = 0 ,$$ and $$ \varepsilon i = (e_1 e_2 e_3 e_4) e_2 e_3 = e_1 e_2 e_3 e_4 e_2 e_3 = e_2 e_3 (e_1 e_2 e_3 e_4) = i\varepsilon.$$ The exchanges of $v, w$ and $R^{4}$ alternate signs an even number of times, and show the dual unit $R^{4}$ commutes with the quaternion basis elements $R^{3}$.

Examples: in small dimension
Let $v$ be any field of characteristic not $w$.

Dimension 1
For $R^{4}$, if $\{e_{1}, e_{2}, e_{3}, e_{4}\}$ has diagonalization $Cl(R4, d)$, that is there is a non-zero vector $Cl[0](R^{4}, d)$ such that $i, j, k$, then $ε$ is algebra-isomorphic to a $Cl[0] 0,3,1(R)$-algebra generated by an element $e_{1}$ that satisfies $e_{4}$, the quadratic algebra $ε$.

In particular, if $i, j, k$ (that is, $K$ is the zero quadratic form) then $2$ is algebra-isomorphic to the dual numbers algebra over $dim V = 1$.

If $Q$ is a non-zero square in $diag(a)$, then $x$.

Otherwise, $Q(x) = a$ is isomorphic to the quadratic field extension $Cl(V, Q)$ of $K$.

Dimension 2
For $x$, if $x^{2} = a$ has diagonalization $K[X] / (X^{2} − a)$ with non-zero $a = 0$ and $Q$ (which always exists if $Cl(V, Q)$ is non-degenerate), then $K$ is isomorphic to a $a$-algebra generated by elements $K$ and $Cl(V, Q) ≃ K ⊕ K$ that satisfies $Cl(V, Q)$, $K(√a)$ and $K$.

Thus $dim V = 2$ is isomorphic to the (generalized) quaternion algebra $Q$. We retrieve Hamilton's quaternions when $diag(a, b)$, since $a$.

As a special case, if some $b$ in $Q$ satisfies $Cl(V, Q)$, then $K$.

Relation to the exterior algebra
Given a vector space $x$, one can construct the exterior algebra $y$, whose definition is independent of any quadratic form on $x^{2} = a$. It turns out that if $y^{2} = b$ does not have characteristic $xy = −yx$ then there is a natural isomorphism between $Cl(V, Q)$ and $(a, b)_{K}$ considered as vector spaces (and there exists an isomorphism in characteristic two, which may not be natural). This is an algebra isomorphism if and only if $a = b = −1$. One can thus consider the Clifford algebra $H = (−1, −1)_{R}$ as an enrichment (or more precisely, a quantization, cf. the Introduction) of the exterior algebra on $x$ with a multiplication that depends on $V$ (one can still define the exterior product independently of $Q(x) = 1$).

The easiest way to establish the isomorphism is to choose an orthogonal basis $Cl(V, Q) ≃ M_{2}(K)$ for $V$ and extend it to a basis for $⋀V$ as described above. The map $V$ is determined by $$e_{i_1}e_{i_2} \cdots e_{i_k} \mapsto e_{i_1}\wedge e_{i_2}\wedge \cdots \wedge e_{i_k}.$$ Note that this only works if the basis $K$ is orthogonal. One can show that this map is independent of the choice of orthogonal basis and so gives a natural isomorphism.

If the characteristic of $2$ is $⋀V$, one can also establish the isomorphism by antisymmetrizing. Define functions $Cl(V, Q)$ by $$f_k(v_1, \ldots, v_k) = \frac{1}{k!}\sum_{\sigma\in \mathrm{S}_k} \sgn(\sigma)\, v_{\sigma(1)}\cdots v_{\sigma(k)}$$ where the sum is taken over the symmetric group on $Q = 0$ elements, $Cl(V, Q)$. Since $V$ is alternating, it induces a unique linear map $Q$. The direct sum of these maps gives a linear map between $Q$ and ${e_{1}, ..., e_{n}} |undefined$. This map can be shown to be a linear isomorphism, and it is natural.

A more sophisticated way to view the relationship is to construct a filtration on $V$. Recall that the tensor algebra $Cl(V, Q)$ has a natural filtration: $Cl(V, Q) → ⋀V$, where ${e_{1}, ..., e_{n}} |undefined$ contains sums of tensors with order $K$. Projecting this down to the Clifford algebra gives a filtration on $0$. The associated graded algebra $$\operatorname{Gr}_F \operatorname{Cl}(V,Q) = \bigoplus_k F^k/F^{k-1}$$ is naturally isomorphic to the exterior algebra $f_{k} : V × ⋯ × V → Cl(V, Q)$. Since the associated graded algebra of a filtered algebra is always isomorphic to the filtered algebra as filtered vector spaces (by choosing complements of $k$ in $S_{k}$ for all $f_{k}$), this provides an isomorphism (although not a natural one) in any characteristic, even two.

Grading
In the following, assume that the characteristic is not $⋀^{k} V → Cl(V, Q)$.

Clifford algebras are $⋀V$-graded algebras (also known as superalgebras). Indeed, the linear map on $Cl(V, Q)$ defined by $Cl(V, Q)$ (reflection through the origin) preserves the quadratic form $T(V)$ and so by the universal property of Clifford algebras extends to an algebra automorphism $$\alpha: \operatorname{Cl}(V, Q) \to \operatorname{Cl}(V, Q).$$

Since $F^{0} ⊂ F^{1} ⊂ F^{2} ⊂ ⋯$ is an involution (i.e. it squares to the identity) one can decompose $F^{k}$ into positive and negative eigenspaces of $≤ k$ $$\operatorname{Cl}(V, Q) = \operatorname{Cl}^{[0]}(V, Q) \oplus \operatorname{Cl}^{[1]}(V, Q)$$ where $$\operatorname{Cl}^{[i]}(V, Q) = \left\{ x \in \operatorname{Cl}(V, Q) \mid \alpha(x) = (-1)^i x \right\}.$$

Since $Cl(V, Q)$ is an automorphism it follows that: $$\operatorname{Cl}^{[i]}(V, Q)\operatorname{Cl}^{[j]}(V, Q) = \operatorname{Cl}^{[i+j]}(V, Q)$$ where the bracketed superscripts are read modulo 2. This gives $⋀V$ the structure of a $F^{k}$-graded algebra. The subspace $F^{k+1}$ forms a subalgebra of $k$, called the even subalgebra. The subspace $2$ is called the odd part of $K[Z / 2Z]$ (it is not a subalgebra). $Z_{2}$-grading plays an important role in the analysis and application of Clifford algebras. The automorphism $V$ is called the main involution or grade involution. Elements that are pure in this $v ↦ −v$-grading are simply said to be even or odd.

Remark. The Clifford algebra is not a $Q$-graded algebra, but is $α$-filtered, where $Cl(V, Q)$ is the subspace spanned by all products of at most $α$ elements of $α$. $$\operatorname{Cl}^{\leqslant i}(V, Q) \cdot \operatorname{Cl}^{\leqslant j}(V, Q) \subset \operatorname{Cl}^{\leqslant i+j}(V, Q).$$

The degree of a Clifford number usually refers to the degree in the $Cl(V, Q)$-grading.

The even subalgebra $Z_{2}$ of a Clifford algebra is itself isomorphic to a Clifford algebra. If $Cl[0](V, Q)$ is the orthogonal direct sum of a vector $Cl(V, Q)$ of nonzero norm $Cl[1](V, Q)$ and a subspace $Cl(V, Q)$, then $This Z_{2}$ is isomorphic to $α$, where $Z_{2}$ is the form $Z$ restricted to $Z$. In particular over the reals this implies that: $$\operatorname{Cl}_{p,q}^{[0]}(\mathbf{R}) \cong \begin{cases} \operatorname{Cl}_{p,q-1}(\mathbf{R}) & q > 0 \\ \operatorname{Cl}_{q,p-1}(\mathbf{R}) & p > 0 \end{cases}$$

In the negative-definite case this gives an inclusion $Cl≤i(V, Q)$, which extends the sequence

Likewise, in the complex case, one can show that the even subalgebra of $i$ is isomorphic to $V$.

Antiautomorphisms
In addition to the automorphism $Z$, there are two antiautomorphisms that play an important role in the analysis of Clifford algebras. Recall that the tensor algebra $Cl[0](V, Q)$ comes with an antiautomorphism that reverses the order in all products of vectors: $$v_1\otimes v_2\otimes \cdots \otimes v_k \mapsto v_k\otimes \cdots \otimes v_2\otimes v_1.$$ Since the ideal $2$ is invariant under this reversal, this operation descends to an antiautomorphism of $V$ called the transpose or reversal operation, denoted by $a$. The transpose is an antiautomorphism: $Q(a)$. The transpose operation makes no use of the $U$-grading so we define a second antiautomorphism by composing $Cl[0](V, Q)$ and the transpose. We call this operation Clifford conjugation denoted $$\bar x$$ $$\bar x = \alpha(x^\mathrm{t}) = \alpha(x)^\mathrm{t}.$$ Of the two antiautomorphisms, the transpose is the more fundamental.

Note that all of these operations are involutions. One can show that they act as $Cl(U, −Q(a)Q|)$ on elements that are pure in the $Q|$-grading. In fact, all three operations depend only on the degree modulo $Q$. That is, if $U$ is pure with degree $Cl0,n−1(R) ⊂ Cl0,n(R)$ then $$\alpha(x) = \pm x \qquad x^\mathrm{t} = \pm x \qquad \bar x = \pm x$$ where the signs are given by the following table:

Clifford scalar product
When the characteristic is not $R ⊂ C ⊂ H ⊂ H ⊕ H ⊂ ⋯$, the quadratic form $Cln(C)$ on $Cln−1(C)$ can be extended to a quadratic form on all of $α$ (which we also denoted by $T(V)$). A basis-independent definition of one such extension is $$Q(x) = \left\langle x^\mathrm{t} x\right\rangle_0$$ where $I_{Q}$ denotes the scalar part of $Cl(V, Q)$ (the degree-$x^{t}$ part in the $(xy)^{t} = y^{t} x^{t}$-grading). One can show that $$Q(v_1v_2 \cdots v_k) = Q(v_1)Q(v_2) \cdots Q(v_k)$$ where the $Z_{2}$ are elements of $α$ – this identity is not true for arbitrary elements of $v^{−1} = v^{t} / Q(v)$.

The associated symmetric bilinear form on $v^{−1} = \overline{v} / Q(v)$ is given by $$\langle x, y\rangle = \left\langle x^\mathrm{t} y\right\rangle_0.$$ One can check that this reduces to the original bilinear form when restricted to $±1$. The bilinear form on all of $Z$ is nondegenerate if and only if it is nondegenerate on $4$.

The operator of left (respectively right) Clifford multiplication by the transpose $x$ of an element $k$ is the adjoint of left (respectively right) Clifford multiplication by $k mod 4$ with respect to this inner product. That is, $$\langle ax, y\rangle = \left\langle x, a^\mathrm{t} y\right\rangle,$$ and $$\langle xa, y\rangle = \left\langle x, y a^\mathrm{t}\right\rangle.$$

Structure of Clifford algebras
In this section we assume that characteristic is not $0$, the vector space $1$ is finite-dimensional and that the associated symmetric bilinear form of $2$ is nondegenerate.

A central simple algebra over $3$ is a matrix algebra over a (finite-dimensional) division algebra with center $+$. For example, the central simple algebras over the reals are matrix algebras over either the reals or the quaternions.
 * If $−$ has even dimension then $+$ is a central simple algebra over $−$.
 * If $(−1)^{k}$ has even dimension then the even subalgebra $+$ is a central simple algebra over a quadratic extension of $+$ or a sum of two isomorphic central simple algebras over $−$.
 * If $−$ has odd dimension then $(−1)^{k(k − 1)/2}$ is a central simple algebra over a quadratic extension of $+$ or a sum of two isomorphic central simple algebras over $−$.
 * If $−$ has odd dimension then the even subalgebra $+$ is a central simple algebra over $(−1)^{k(k + 1)/2}$.

The structure of Clifford algebras can be worked out explicitly using the following result. Suppose that $2$ has even dimension and a non-singular bilinear form with discriminant $Q$, and suppose that $V$ is another vector space with a quadratic form. The Clifford algebra of $Cl(V, Q)$ is isomorphic to the tensor product of the Clifford algebras of $Q$ and $⟨a⟩0$, which is the space $a$ with its quadratic form multiplied by $0$. Over the reals, this implies in particular that $$ \operatorname{Cl}_{p+2,q}(\mathbf{R}) = \mathrm{M}_2(\mathbf{R})\otimes \operatorname{Cl}_{q,p}(\mathbf{R}) $$ $$ \operatorname{Cl}_{p+1,q+1}(\mathbf{R}) = \mathrm{M}_2(\mathbf{R})\otimes \operatorname{Cl}_{p,q}(\mathbf{R}) $$ $$ \operatorname{Cl}_{p,q+2}(\mathbf{R}) = \mathbf{H}\otimes \operatorname{Cl}_{q,p}(\mathbf{R}). $$ These formulas can be used to find the structure of all real Clifford algebras and all complex Clifford algebras; see the classification of Clifford algebras.

Notably, the Morita equivalence class of a Clifford algebra (its representation theory: the equivalence class of the category of modules over it) depends only on the signature $Z$. This is an algebraic form of Bott periodicity.

Lipschitz group
The class of Lipschitz groups (a.k.a. Clifford groups or Clifford–Lipschitz groups) was discovered by Rudolf Lipschitz.

In this section we assume that $v_{i}$ is finite-dimensional and the quadratic form $V$ is nondegenerate.

An action on the elements of a Clifford algebra by its group of units may be defined in terms of a twisted conjugation: twisted conjugation by $Cl(V, Q)$ maps $Cl(V, Q)$, where $V$ is the main involution defined above.

The Lipschitz group $Cl(V, Q)$ is defined to be the set of invertible elements $V$ that stabilize the set of vectors under this action, meaning that for all $a$ in $a$ we have: $$\alpha(x) v x^{-1}\in V .$$

This formula also defines an action of the Lipschitz group on the vector space $a$ that preserves the quadratic form $2$, and so gives a homomorphism from the Lipschitz group to the orthogonal group. The Lipschitz group contains all elements $V$ of $Q$ for which $K$ is invertible in $K$, and these act on $V$ by the corresponding reflections that take $Cl(V, Q)$ to $K$. (In characteristic $V$ these are called orthogonal transvections rather than reflections.)

If $Cl[0](V, Q)$ is a finite-dimensional real vector space with a non-degenerate quadratic form then the Lipschitz group maps onto the orthogonal group of $K$ with respect to the form (by the Cartan–Dieudonné theorem) and the kernel consists of the nonzero elements of the field $K$. This leads to exact sequences $$ 1 \rightarrow K^\times \rightarrow \Gamma \rightarrow \operatorname{O}_V(K) \rightarrow 1,$$ $$ 1 \rightarrow K^\times \rightarrow \Gamma^0 \rightarrow \operatorname{SO}_V(K) \rightarrow 1.$$

Over other fields or with indefinite forms, the map is not in general onto, and the failure is captured by the spinor norm.

Spinor norm
In arbitrary characteristic, the spinor norm $V$ is defined on the Lipschitz group by $$Q(x) = x^\mathrm{t}x.$$ It is a homomorphism from the Lipschitz group to the group $Cl(V, Q)$ of non-zero elements of $K$. It coincides with the quadratic form $K$ of $V$ when $Cl[0](V, Q)$ is identified with a subspace of the Clifford algebra. Several authors define the spinor norm slightly differently, so that it differs from the one here by a factor of $K$, $U$, or $d$ on $V$. The difference is not very important in characteristic other than 2.

The nonzero elements of $U + V$ have spinor norm in the group ($U$ of squares of nonzero elements of the field $(−1)^{dim(U)/2}dV$. So when $V$ is finite-dimensional and non-singular we get an induced map from the orthogonal group of $(−1)^{dim(U)/2}d$ to the group $(p − q) mod 8$, also called the spinor norm. The spinor norm of the reflection about $V$, for any vector $Q$, has image $x$ in $y ↦ α(x) y x^{−1}$, and this property uniquely defines it on the orthogonal group. This gives exact sequences: $$\begin{align} 1 \to \{\pm 1\} \to \operatorname{Pin}_V(K)  &\to \operatorname{O}_V(K)  \to K^\times/\left(K^\times\right)^2, \\  1 \to \{\pm 1\} \to \operatorname{Spin}_V(K) &\to \operatorname{SO}_V(K) \to K^\times/\left(K^\times\right)^2. \end{align}$$

Note that in characteristic $α$ the group $Γ$ has just one element.

From the point of view of Galois cohomology of algebraic groups, the spinor norm is a connecting homomorphism on cohomology. Writing $x$ for the algebraic group of square roots of 1 (over a field of characteristic not $v$ it is roughly the same as a two-element group with trivial Galois action), the short exact sequence $$ 1 \to \mu_2 \rightarrow \operatorname{Pin}_V \rightarrow \operatorname{O}_V \rightarrow 1$$ yields a long exact sequence on cohomology, which begins $$ 1 \to H^0(\mu_2; K) \to H^0(\operatorname{Pin}_V; K) \to H^0(\operatorname{O}_V; K) \to H^1(\mu_2; K).$$

The 0th Galois cohomology group of an algebraic group with coefficients in $V$ is just the group of $V$-valued points: $Q$, and $r$, which recovers the previous sequence $$ 1 \to \{\pm 1\} \to \operatorname{Pin}_V(K) \to \operatorname{O}_V(K) \to K^\times/\left(K^\times\right)^2,$$ where the spinor norm is the connecting homomorphism $V$.

Spin and pin groups
In this section we assume that $Q(r)$ is finite-dimensional and its bilinear form is non-singular.

The pin group $K$ is the subgroup of the Lipschitz group $V$ of elements of spinor norm $v$, and similarly the spin group $v − ( + )r / Q(r)$ is the subgroup of elements of Dickson invariant $2$ in $V$. When the characteristic is not $V$, these are the elements of determinant $K$. The spin group usually has index $Q$ in the pin group.

Recall from the previous section that there is a homomorphism from the Lipschitz group onto the orthogonal group. We define the special orthogonal group to be the image of $K^{×}$. If $K$ does not have characteristic $Q$ this is just the group of elements of the orthogonal group of determinant $V$. If $V$ does have characteristic $−1$, then all elements of the orthogonal group have determinant $2$, and the special orthogonal group is the set of elements of Dickson invariant $−2$.

There is a homomorphism from the pin group to the orthogonal group. The image consists of the elements of spinor norm $Γ^{1}$. The kernel consists of the elements $K$ and $K^{×})^{2}$, and has order $K$ unless $V$ has characteristic $V$. Similarly there is a homomorphism from the Spin group to the special orthogonal group of $K^{×} / (K^{×})^{2}$.

In the common case when $r^{⊥}$ is a positive or negative definite space over the reals, the spin group maps onto the special orthogonal group, and is simply connected when $r$ has dimension at least $Q(r)$. Further the kernel of this homomorphism consists of $K^{×} / (K^{×})^{2}$ and $2$. So in this case the spin group, $\{±1\}$, is a double cover of $μ_{2}$. Please note, however, that the simple connectedness of the spin group is not true in general: if $2$ is $K$ for $K$ and $H^{0}(G; K) = G(K)$ both at least $H^{1}(μ_{2}; K) ≅ K^{×} / (K^{×})^{2}$ then the spin group is not simply connected. In this case the algebraic group $H^{0}(O_{V}; K) → H^{1}(μ_{2}; K)$ is simply connected as an algebraic group, even though its group of real valued points $V$ is not simply connected. This is a rather subtle point, which completely confused the authors of at least one standard book about spin groups.

Spinors
Clifford algebras $Pin_{V}(K)$, with $Γ$ even, are matrix algebras that have a complex representation of dimension $1$. By restricting to the group $Spin_{V}(K)$ we get a complex representation of the Pin group of the same dimension, called the spin representation. If we restrict this to the spin group $0$ then it splits as the sum of two half spin representations (or Weyl representations) of dimension $Pin_{V}(K)$.

If $2$ is odd then the Clifford algebra $1$ is a sum of two matrix algebras, each of which has a representation of dimension $2$, and these are also both representations of the pin group $Γ^{0}$. On restriction to the spin group $K$ these become isomorphic, so the spin group has a complex spinor representation of dimension $2$.

More generally, spinor groups and pin groups over any field have similar representations whose exact structure depends on the structure of the corresponding Clifford algebras: whenever a Clifford algebra has a factor that is a matrix algebra over some division algebra, we get a corresponding representation of the pin and spin groups over that division algebra. For examples over the reals see the article on spinors.

Real spinors
To describe the real spin representations, one must know how the spin group sits inside its Clifford algebra. The pin group, $1$ is the set of invertible elements in $K$ that can be written as a product of unit vectors: $$\mathrm{Pin}_{p,q} = \left\{v_1v_2 \cdots v_r \mid \forall i\, \|v_i\| = \pm 1\right\}.$$ Comparing with the above concrete realizations of the Clifford algebras, the pin group corresponds to the products of arbitrarily many reflections: it is a cover of the full orthogonal group $2$. The spin group consists of those elements of $1$ that are products of an even number of unit vectors. Thus by the Cartan–Dieudonné theorem Spin is a cover of the group of proper rotations $0$.

Let $1 ∈ K^{×} / (K^{×})^{2}$ be the automorphism that is given by the mapping $+1$ acting on pure vectors. Then in particular, $−1$ is the subgroup of $2$ whose elements are fixed by $K$. Let $$\operatorname{Cl}_{p,q}^{[0]} = \{ x\in \operatorname{Cl}_{p,q} \mid \alpha(x) = x\}.$$ (These are precisely the elements of even degree in $2$.) Then the spin group lies within $V$.

The irreducible representations of $V$ restrict to give representations of the pin group. Conversely, since the pin group is generated by unit vectors, all of its irreducible representation are induced in this manner. Thus the two representations coincide. For the same reasons, the irreducible representations of the spin coincide with the irreducible representations of $V$.

To classify the pin representations, one need only appeal to the classification of Clifford algebras. To find the spin representations (which are representations of the even subalgebra), one can first make use of either of the isomorphisms (see above) $$\operatorname{Cl}^{[0]}_{p,q} \approx \operatorname{Cl}_{p,q-1}, \text{ for } q > 0$$ $$\operatorname{Cl}^{[0]}_{p,q} \approx \operatorname{Cl}_{q,p-1}, \text{ for } p > 0$$ and realize a spin representation in signature $3$ as a pin representation in either signature $1$ or $−1$.

Differential geometry
One of the principal applications of the exterior algebra is in differential geometry where it is used to define the bundle of differential forms on a smooth manifold. In the case of a (pseudo-)Riemannian manifold, the tangent spaces come equipped with a natural quadratic form induced by the metric. Thus, one can define a Clifford bundle in analogy with the exterior bundle. This has a number of important applications in Riemannian geometry. Perhaps more important is the link to a spin manifold, its associated spinor bundle and $Spin(n)$ manifolds.

Physics
Clifford algebras have numerous important applications in physics. Physicists usually consider a Clifford algebra to be an algebra that has a basis that is generated by the matrices $SO(n)$, called Dirac matrices, which have the property that $$\gamma_i\gamma_j + \gamma_j\gamma_i = 2\eta_{ij} ,$$ where $V$ is the matrix of a quadratic form of signature $R^{p,q}$ (or $p$ corresponding to the two equivalent choices of metric signature). These are exactly the defining relations for the Clifford algebra $q$, whose complexification is $2$, which, by the classification of Clifford algebras, is isomorphic to the algebra of $Spin_{p,q}$ complex matrices $Spin_{p,q}(R)$. However, it is best to retain the notation $Clp,q(C)$, since any transformation that takes the bilinear form to the canonical form is not a Lorentz transformation of the underlying spacetime.

The Clifford algebra of spacetime used in physics thus has more structure than $p + q = 2n$. It has in addition a set of preferred transformations – Lorentz transformations. Whether complexification is necessary to begin with depends in part on conventions used and in part on how much one wants to incorporate straightforwardly, but complexification is most often necessary in quantum mechanics where the spin representation of the Lie algebra $2^{n}$ sitting inside the Clifford algebra conventionally requires a complex Clifford algebra. For reference, the spin Lie algebra is given by $$\begin{align} \sigma^{\mu\nu} &= -\frac{i}{4}\left[\gamma^\mu,\, \gamma^\nu\right], \\ \left[\sigma^{\mu\nu},\, \sigma^{\rho\tau}\right] &= i\left(\eta^{\tau\mu}\sigma^{\rho\nu} + \eta^{\nu\tau}\sigma^{\mu\rho} - \eta^{\rho\mu}\sigma^{\tau\nu} - \eta^{\nu\rho} \sigma^{\mu\tau}\right). \end{align}$$

This is in the $Pin_{p,q}(R)$ convention, hence fits in $Spin_{p,q}(R)$.

The Dirac matrices were first written down by Paul Dirac when he was trying to write a relativistic first-order wave equation for the electron, and give an explicit isomorphism from the Clifford algebra to the algebra of complex matrices. The result was used to define the Dirac equation and introduce the Dirac operator. The entire Clifford algebra shows up in quantum field theory in the form of Dirac field bilinears.

The use of Clifford algebras to describe quantum theory has been advanced among others by Mario Schönberg, by David Hestenes in terms of geometric calculus, by David Bohm and Basil Hiley and co-workers in form of a hierarchy of Clifford algebras, and by Elio Conte et al.

Computer vision
Clifford algebras have been applied in the problem of action recognition and classification in computer vision. Rodriguez et al propose a Clifford embedding to generalize traditional MACH filters to video (3D spatiotemporal volume), and vector-valued data such as optical flow. Vector-valued data is analyzed using the Clifford Fourier Transform. Based on these vectors action filters are synthesized in the Clifford Fourier domain and recognition of actions is performed using Clifford correlation. The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of the Clifford embedding by recognizing actions typically performed in classic feature films and sports broadcast television.

Generalizations

 * While this article focuses on a Clifford algebra of a vector space over a field, the definition extends without change to a module over any unital, associative, commutative ring.
 * Clifford algebras may be generalized to a form of degree higher than quadratic over a vector space.

title: Clifford algebra


text:
Kyzylkum Desert

The Kyzylkum Desert (Qizilqum, Қизилқум, قِیزِیل‌قُوم; Қызылқұм, قىزىلقۇم) is the 15th largest desert in the world. Its name means Red Sand in Turkic languages. It is located in Central Asia, in the land between the confluent rivers Amu Darya and Syr Darya, a region historically known as Transoxania. Today it is divided among Kazakhstan, Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan. It covers about 298000 km2.

Geography
Kyzylkum is mainly located in Uzbekistan. Its territory consists mainly of an extensive plain at an altitude up to 300 m above sea level, with a number of depressions and highlands (Sultanuizdag, Bukantau). Most of the area is covered with dunes (barchans); in the northwest large areas are covered with takirs (clay coatings); there are also some oases. There are agricultural settlements along the rivers and in the oases. Temperatures can be very high during the summer months, from mid-May to mid-September. Kerki, one extreme inland city located on the banks of the Amu Darya River, recorded 52 C in July 1983.

Fauna
Desert fauna include the Russian tortoise (Testudo horsfieldii) and a large lizard known as the Transcaspian or desert monitor (Varanus griseus), which can reach lengths of 1.6 m. The saiga antelope (Saiga tatarica) also occasionally migrates through the northern part of the desert.

Kyzylkum Nature Reserve in Bukhara Region was established in 1971. The area of the reserve amounts to 101000 km2 and it is located on flood-land (tugai) drained by the Amudarya close to the settlement Dargan Ata. Fauna include: Bactrian deer (Cervus elaphus bactrianus), wild boar (Sus scrofa), common pheasant (Phasianus colchicus), golden eagle (Aquila chrysaetus).

Djeyran Reserve is located 40 km south of Bukhara. The total area of this reserve is 51450 km2. It is a breeding centre for rare species such as goitered gazelle (Gazella subgutturosa), Przewalski's horse (Equus ferus przewalskii), Turkmenian kulan (Equus hemionus kulan) and MacQueen's bustard (Chlamydotis macqueenii). The reserve was founded in 1977 on the enclosed area in 5131 ha.

Paleontology

The Kyzylkum Desert has exposed rock formations that have yielded a number of fossils. Of particular interest is the Bissekty Formation of Uzbekistan, from the early Late Cretaceous, which has produced several species of early birds: Incolornis martini, Explorornis walkeri, Kizylkumavis cretacea, Kuszholia mengi, Lenesornis kaskarovi, Sazavis prisca, Zhyraornis kaskarovi and Z. logunovi are recognized as valid species. Tyrannosaurid, therizinosaurid, ornithomimosaur, oviraptorosaurian, troodontid, ankylosaur, hadrosaur, and ceratopsian dinosaurs are also known from this rock unit. Other fossils from the Cretaceous rocks of the Kyzylkum include tree trunks, pelecypods, beetles, sharks, rays, bony fish, frogs, salamanders, turtles, crocodylomorphs, pterosaurs, and a varied fauna of small early mammals. Paleontologists that have worked in this area include J. David Archibald, Alexander Averianov, Sergei Kurzanov, Lev Nesov, Anatoly Riabinin, Anatoly Rozhdestvensky, and Hans-Dieter Sues.

Economy
The local population uses the large spaces of the Kyzylkum Desert as a pasture for livestock (mostly sheep, Bactrian camels and dromedaries).

The desert is well known for its deposits of gold, uranium, copper, aluminium and silver, natural gas and oil. The development of the most famous gold-field at Muruntau began in the early 1970s. The centres for the mining and smelting industry at the region are Navoi, Zarafshan, Uchkuduk. The major industrial enterprises are: НГМК (Navoi Mining and Smelting Complex) and the Uzbek U.S.A. Joint Venture "Zarafshan-Newmont". The centres of the gas-production industry are Gazli and Mubarek.

license: Creative Commons - Attribution Share-Alike - https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/

title: Kyzylkum Desert


text:
Atomic electron transition

In atomic physics and chemistry, an atomic electron transition (also called an atomic transition, quantum jump, or quantum leap) is an electron changing from one energy level to another within an atom or artificial atom. The time scale of a quantum jump has not been measured experimentally. However, the Franck–Condon principle binds the upper limit of this parameter to the order of attoseconds.

Electrons jumping to energy levels of smaller n emit electromagnetic radiation in the form of a photon. Electrons can also absorb passing photons, which drives a quantum jump to a level of higher n. The larger the energy separation between the electron's initial and final state, the shorter the photons' wavelength.

History
Danish physicist Niels Bohr first theorized that electrons can perform quantum jumps in 1913. Soon after, James Franck and Gustav Ludwig Hertz proved experimentally that atoms have quantized energy states.

The observability of quantum jumps was predicted by Hans Dehmelt in 1975, and they were first observed using trapped ions of barium at University of Hamburg and mercury at NIST in 1986.

Theory
An atom interacts with the oscillating electric field:

with amplitude $$|\textbf{E}_0|$$, angular frequency $$\omega$$, and polarization vector $$\hat{\textbf{e}}_\mathrm{rad}$$. Note that the actual phase is $$ (\omega t - \textbf{k} \cdot \textbf{r}) $$. However, in many cases, the variation of $$ \textbf{k} \cdot \textbf{r} $$ is small over the atom (or equivalently, the radiation wavelength is much greater than the size of an atom) and this term can be ignored. This is called the dipole approximation. The atom can also interact with the oscillating magnetic field produced by the radiation, although much more weakly.

The Hamiltonian for this interaction, analogous to the energy of a classical dipole in an electric field, is $$ H_I = e \textbf{r} \cdot \textbf{E}(t) $$. The stimulated transition rate can be calculated using time-dependent perturbation theory; however, the result can be summarized using Fermi's golden rule: $$ Rate \propto |eE_0|^2 \times | \lang 2 | \textbf{r} \cdot \hat{\textbf{e}}_\mathrm{rad} |1 \rang |^2 $$ The dipole matrix element can be decomposed into the product of the radial integral and the angular integral. The angular integral is zero unless the selection rules for the atomic transition are satisfied.

Recent discoveries
In 2019, it was demonstrated in an experiment with a superconducting artificial atom consisting of two strongly-hybridized transmon qubits placed inside a readout resonator cavity at 15 mK, that the evolution of some jumps is continuous, coherent, deterministic, and reversible. On the other hand, other quantum jumps are inherently unpredictable.

title: Atomic electron transition


text:
Talk:Natural Capitalism

Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment
This article was the subject of a Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment, between 24 August 2020 and 12 December 2020. Further details are available on the course page. Student editor(s): Gusconn.

Above undated message substituted from Template:Dashboard.wikiedu.org assignment by PrimeBOT (talk) 04:59, 17 January 2022 (UTC)

Untitled
How might this entry address critiques about the commodification of nature or how people actually go about setting a price on ecosystem services? Drmedwards (talk) 20:11, 16 September 2020 (UTC)

This entry isn't even a stub yet (barely a definition); still needs to say what Natural Capitalism is, not just what it does --maveric149
 * there are four trends listed in the HLL book, up front somewhere.

Sounds interesting though. I tried to check out the reference site at the bottom .... natcap.org .... but it was not available when I tried. I will try it again later.

This looks like an emerging field, topic or definition. I suspect some will not like this .... I think it may be appropriate as long as it is dated as this is ...
 * it isn't, really, the UN now uses the term "natural capital" - and once bureaucrats get ahold of something... the "ism" refers to the use of the standard neoclassical economics models, as Hawken, Lovins, and Lovins do, i.e. they believe capitalism works when you set up the political economy right.

how else to keep wikipedia current? Presumabably the new few thousand readers will have bold editors to delete or annotate information that goes out of fashion???? :)

Got over 200K google hits on "Natural Capitalism"! Apparently very real chance this will remain in the lexicon.

user:mirwin

 * I attempted to add a basic description of the essential elements of the theory. -- M0llusk (talk) 03:37, 17 December 2008 (UTC)

The modified title seems wrong. That is the full title of the book, but the book is about a concept which is the same as the primary title. The correct title for this page and the discussion page is the more simple "Natural Capitalism" that it started with. The full title of the book as published can be noted in the text and references. -- M0llusk (talk) 21:13, 21 February 2009 (UTC)

External links modified
Hello fellow Wikipedians,

I have just modified one external link on Natural Capitalism. Please take a moment to review my edit. If you have any questions, or need the bot to ignore the links, or the page altogether, please visit this simple FaQ for additional information. I made the following changes:
 * Added archive https://web.archive.org/web/20150525012029/http://www.worldchanging.com/archives/010556.html to http://www.worldchanging.com/archives/010556.html

When you have finished reviewing my changes, you may follow the instructions on the template below to fix any issues with the URLs.

Cheers.— InternetArchiveBot  (Report bug) 07:41, 3 December 2017 (UTC)

title: Talk:Natural Capitalism


text:
Qattara Depression

The Qattara Depression (منخفض القطارة) is a depression in northwestern Egypt, specifically in the Matruh Governorate. The depression is part of the Western Desert of Egypt. The Qattara Depression lies below sea level, and its bottom is covered with salt pans, sand dunes, and salt marshes. The depression extends between the latitudes of 28°35' and 30°25' north and the longitudes of 26°20' and 29°02' east.

The Qattara Depression was created by the interplay of salt weathering and wind erosion. Some 20 km west of the depression lie the oases of Siwa in Egypt and Jaghbub in Libya in smaller but similar depressions.

The Qattara Depression contains the second lowest point in Africa at an elevation of 133 m below sea level, the lowest point being Lake Assal in Djibouti. The depression covers about 19605 km2, a size comparable with Lake Ontario or twice as large as Lebanon. Due to its size and proximity to the shores of the Mediterranean Sea, studies have been made proposing to flood the area for various usages, such as the potential to generate hydroelectricity there.

Geography

The Qattara Depression has the shape of a teardrop, with its point facing east and the broad deep area facing southwest. The northern side of the depression is characterised by steep escarpments up to 280 m high, marking the edge of the adjacent El Diffa plateau. To the south the depression slopes gently up to the Great Sand Sea.

Within the Depression are salt marshes, under the northwestern and northern escarpment edges, and extensive dry lake beds that flood occasionally. The marshes occupy approximately 300 km2, although wind-blown sands are encroaching in some areas. About a quarter of the region is occupied by dry lakes composed of hard crust and sticky mud, and occasionally filled with water.

The depression was initiated by either wind or fluvial erosion in the late Neogene, but during the Quaternary Period the dominant mechanism was a combination of salt weathering and wind erosion working together. First, the salts break up the depression floor, then the wind blows away the resulting sands. This process is less effective in the eastern part of the depression, due to lower salinity groundwater.

Ecology

Groves of umbrella thorn acacia (Vachellia tortilis), growing in shallow sandy depressions, and Phragmites swamps represent the only permanent vegetation. The acacia groves vary widely in biodiversity and rely on runoff from rainfall and groundwater to survive. The Moghra Oasis in the northeastern part of the Depression has a 4 km2 brackish lake and a Phragmites swamp.

The southwestern corner of the depression is part of the Siwa Protected Area which protects the wild oasis in and around the Siwa Oasis.

The Depression is an important habitat for the cheetah, with the largest number of recent sightings being in areas in the northern, western and northwestern part of the Qattara Depression, including the highly isolated, wild oases of Ain EI Qattara and Ein EI Ghazzalat and numerous acacia groves both inside and outside the depression.

Gazelles (Gazella dorcas and Gazella leptoceros) also inhabit the Qattara Depression, being an important food source for the cheetah. The largest gazelle population exists in the southwestern part of the Qattara Depression within a vast area of wetlands and soft sand. The area of 900 km2, includes the wild oases of Hatiyat Tabaghbagh and Hatiyat Umm Kitabain, and is a mosaic of lakes, salt marshes, scrubland, wild palm groves and Desmostachya bipinnata grassland.

Other common fauna include the Cape hare (Lepus capensis), Egyptian jackal (Canis aureus hupstar), sand fox (Vulpes rueppelli) and more rarely the fennec fox (Vulpes zerda). Barbary sheep (Ammotragus lervia) were once common here but now they are few in number.

Extinct species from the area include the scimitar oryx (Oryx dammah), addax (Addax nasomaculatus) and bubal hartebeest (Alcelaphus buselaphus). Also the Droseridites baculatus, an extinct plant known only from fossils of its pollen, was found at the Ghazalat-1 Well.

Climate
The climate of the Qattara Depression is highly arid with annual precipitation between 25 and 50 mm on the northern rim to less than 25 mm in the south of the depression. The average daily temperature varies between 36.2 to 6.2 C during summer and winter months. The prevailing wind forms a largely bimodal regime with most wind coming from north easterly and westerly directions. This causes the linear dune formations in the Western desert between the Qattara Depression and the Nile valley. Wind speeds peak in March at 11.5 m/s and minimal in December at 3.2 m/s. The average wind speed is about 5 to 6 m/s. Several days each year in the months March to May khamsin winds blow in from the south and bringing extremely high temperatures as well as sand and dust with them.

Land use
There is one permanent settlement in the Qattara Depression, the Qara Oasis. The oasis is located in the westernmost part of the depression and is inhabited by about 300 people. The Depression is also inhabited by the nomadic Bedouin people and their flocks, with the uninhabited Moghra Oasis being important in times of water scarcity during the dry seasons.

The Qattara Depression contains many oil concessions, and several operational oil fields. The drilling companies include Royal Dutch Shell and the Apache Corporation.

Measurement
The elevation of the depression was first measured in 1917 by an officer of the British Army leading a light car patrol into the region. The officer took readings of the height of the terrain with an aneroid barometer on behalf of John Ball, who later would also publish on the region. He discovered that the spring Ain EI Qattara lay about 60 m below sea level. Because the barometer got lost and the readings were so unexpected, this find had to be verified. During 1924–25, Ball again organised a survey party, this time with the sole purpose to triangulate the elevation on a westerly line from Wadi El Natrun. The survey was led by G.F. Walpole who had already distinguished himself by triangulating the terrain across 500 km from the Nile to Siwa via Bahariya. He confirmed the earlier readings and proved the presence of a huge area below sea level, with places as deep as 133 m below sea level.

Knowledge about the geology of the Qattara Depression was greatly extended by Ralph Alger Bagnold, a British military commander and explorer, through numerous journeys in the 1920s and 1930s. Most notable was his 1927 journey during which he crossed the depression east to west and visited the oases of Qara and Siwa. Many of these trips used motor vehicles (Ford Model-Ts) which used special techniques for driving in desert conditions. These techniques were an important asset of the Long Range Desert Group which Bagnold founded in 1940.

After the discovery of the depression, Ball published the triangulation findings about the region in October 1927 in The Geographical Journal. He also gave the region its name "Qattara" after the spring Ain EI Qattara where the first readings were taken. The name literally means "dripping" in Arabic. Six years later in 1933, Ball was the first to publish a proposal for flooding the region to generate hydroelectric power in his article "The Qattara Depression of the Libyan Desert and the possibility of its utilisation for power-production".

World War II
During World War II, the depression's presence shaped the First and Second Battles of El Alamein. It was considered impassable by tanks and most other military vehicles because of features such as salt lakes, high cliffs and/or escarpments, and fech fech (very fine powdered sand). The cliffs in particular acted as an edge of the El Alamein battlefield, which meant the British Empire's forces could not be outflanked to the south. Both Axis and Allied forces built their defences in a line from the Mediterranean Sea to the Qattara Depression. These defences became known as the Devil's gardens, and they are for the most part still there, especially the extensive minefields.

No large army units entered the Depression, although German Afrika Korps patrols and the British Long Range Desert Group did operate in the area, since these small units had considerable experience in desert travel. The RAF's repair and salvage units (e.g. 58 RSU) used a route through the depression to salvage or recover aircraft that had landed or crashed in the Western desert away from the coastal plain.

The RSUs included six-wheel-drive trucks, Coles cranes, and large trailers, and were particularly active from mid-1941 when Air Vice-Marshal G.G. Dawson arrived in Egypt to address the lack of serviceable aircraft.

A German communications officer stationed in the depression was cited by Gordon Welchman as being unintentionally helpful in the breaking of the Enigma machine code, due to his regular transmissions stating there was "nothing to report".

Qattara Depression Project
The large size of the Qattara Depression and the fact that it falls to a depth of 133 m below mean sea level has led to several proposals to create a massive hydroelectric power project in northern Egypt rivalling that of the Aswan High Dam. This project is known as the Qattara Depression Project. The proposals call for a large canal or tunnel being excavated from the Qattara due north of 55 to 80 km depending on the route chosen to the Mediterranean Sea to bring seawater into the area.

An alternative plan involved running a 320 km pipeline northeast to the freshwater Nile River at Rosetta. Water would flow into a series of water penstocks which would generate electricity by releasing the water at 60 m below sea level. Because the Qattara Depression is in a very hot dry region with very little cloud cover, the water released at the -70 m level would spread out from the release point across the basin and evaporate from solar influx. Because of evaporation, more water can flow into the depression, thus forming a continual source of power. Eventually this would result in a hypersaline lake or a salt pan as the water would evaporate and leave behind the salt that it contained.

Plans to use the Qattara Depression for the generation of electricity date back to 1912 from Berlin geographer Albrecht Penck. The subject was discussed in more detail by Dr. John Ball in 1927, who estimated a hydroelectric potential of 125 to 200 megawatts. In 1957, the American Central Intelligence Agency proposed to President Dwight Eisenhower that peace in the Middle East could be achieved by flooding the Qattara Depression. The resulting lagoon, according to the CIA, would have four benefits:

 * it is easier to extract oil from offshore platforms than in swamps
 * the flow will turn the hydroelectric power station
 * fishing, resorts, pearls
 * It would get Egyptian president Gamel Abdel Nasser's "mind on other matters" because "he need[ed] some way to get off the Soviet hook"

In the 1970s and early 1980s, several proposals to flood the area were made by Friedrich Bassler and the Joint Venture Qattara, a group of mainly German companies. They wanted to make use of peaceful nuclear explosions to construct a tunnel, drastically reducing construction costs compared to conventional methods. This project proposed to use 213 H-bombs, with yields of one to 1.5 megatons, detonated at depths of 100 to 500 m. That fit within the Atoms for Peace program proposed by US President Dwight Eisenhower in 1953. The Egyptian government turned down the idea.

Planning experts and scientists intermittently put forward potentially viable options, whether of a tunnel or canal, as an economic, ecological, and energy solution in Egypt, often coupled with the idea of new settlements.

title: Qattara Depression