text:
John Hubley

John Kirkham Hubley (May 21, 1914 – February 21, 1977) was an American animated film director, art director, producer, and writer known for his work with the United Productions of America (UPA) and his own independent studio, Storyboard, Inc. (later renamed Hubley Studio). A pioneer and innovator in the American animation industry, Hubley pushed for more visually and emotionally complex films than those being produced by contemporaries like the Walt Disney Company and Warner Brothers Animation. He and his second wife, Faith Hubley (née Chestman), who he worked alongside from 1953 onward, were nominated for seven Academy Awards, winning three.

Hubley was born in Marinette, Wisconsin, in 1914 and developed an interest in art from a young age, as both his mother and maternal grandfather were professional painters. After high school, Hubley attended the ArtCenter College of Design to study painting. After three years of classes, he got a job at the Walt Disney Animation Studio at the age of 22. Although his talents were recognized by the studio and he was given a position as an animation director on Fantasia, Hubley felt restricted by the studio's conservative animation style. Hubley left Disney in 1941 during the Disney animator's strike and joined the First Motion Pictures Unit, later following many of his fellow unit artists to the newly-formed Industrial Poster Service (later renamed the United Productions of America). Hubley served many roles at UPA and directed several Academy Award-nominated animated shorts. Most famously, he directed The Ragtime Bear (1949), the debut of Mr. Magoo, a character he co-created.

In 1952, Hubley was forced to leave UPA after refusing to denounce communism, leading to his eventual investigation by the House Un-American Activities Committee. He soon opened his own independent studio to capitalize on commercial work for the new market of television advertising, directing the successful "I Want My Maypo!" spot. In 1954, he was commissioned by the Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum to make an animated short film, the first short ever funded by an art museum.

Hubley (alongside his wife Faith) is often considered the most important figure in American independent animation and one of the most important figures in the history of animation. The Hubleys' film Moonbird (1959) became the first independent film to win the Academy Award for Best Animated Short. Hubley collaborated with jazz musicians like Dizzy Gillespie, Benny Carter, and Quincy Jones and often used unscripted, improvised dialogue in his films, creating an entirely new way of expressing emotion and feeling through the medium of animation. His films are considered important in the evolution of post-war modernism in film. The Academy of Motion Pictures Arts and Sciences claim the Hubleys' films "bucked the establishment and defined an era of independent animation production".

Early life and education
Hubley was born on May 21, 1914, at 1212 11th Street (now Shore Drive) in Marinette, Wisconsin. His father, John Raymond Hubley, was a secretary at the John B Goodman Company – a logging company – in Marinette, and his mother, Verena Kirkham Hubley, was a homemaker. Verena's maternal grandfather, Jacob Leisen, was one of the founders of the Leisen & Henes Brewing Company in Menominee, Michigan. The Leisen-Kirkham family were economically stable, allowing Verena's parents to send her to the Art Institute of Chicago, where she studied painting from 1907 to 1909. Verena's father, Richard Archibald Kirkham, was also a painter and one of the earliest photographers in Menominee.

Hubley was encouraged at a young age to become an artist by his mother and maternal grandfather. In a 1974 interview, Hubley stated "I used to watch my grandfather when I was a little kid...It was always ordained that I would go to art school as soon as I got out of high school".

In 1921, John Raymond Hubley partnered with his cousin Loren O. Robeck opened Robeck & Hubley, a Ford dealership at 1919 Hall Avenue in Marinette. The business was only modestly successful and closed in 1928, the same year the Hubleys left Marinette and moved to Iron Mountain, Michigan. Hubley attended Iron Mountain High School from 1929 to 1932. While a student, Hubley would partake in a wide array of extracurricular activities, including the debate, drama, a capella, basketball, Hi-Y (a male-only group associated with the YMCA), and mathematics clubs. Hubley also wrote for the school's newspaper, The Mountaineer, and from 1930 to 1932 provided the illustrations for the school's yearbook, The Argonaut. While in high school, Hubley worked as a bank cashier in Iron Mountain.

In the fall of 1933, Hubley enrolled at the ArtCenter College of Design in Los Angeles, California, to study painting. Unable to support himself, Hubley lived with his aunt, Kathleen Kirkham Woodruff, who had moved to Los Angeles for her film career. Her husband, Harry Woodruff, inspired the character Mr. Magoo. During his time in college, the newly-formed Walt Disney Animation Studio was scouting local art schools for talent. Hubley's painting talents caught the studio's eye, and he was hired as a background and layout artist.

Working at Disney and the 1941 Animator's Strike: 1936–1941
Hubley started working at Walt Disney Productions on January 1, 1936. He started as an apprentice on Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs (1937) producing background tracings and painting backgrounds and layouts for animators. He was quickly promoted to an art director for Pinocchio (1940).

On February 25, 1939, the architect Frank Lloyd Wright visited the studio with a copy of The Tale of the Czar Durandai (1934), a Russian animated film directed by Ivan Ivanov-Vano. Wright showed the film to Disney's staff, including Hubley, who was greatly inspired by the film's stylized visuals and animation.

Hubley was chosen as one of three directors (alongside Dick Kelsey and McLaren Stewart) to handle the "Rite of Spring" passage of Fantasia (1940). Specifically, Hubley directed the section covering the molten stage of Earth's creation to the cooling off into greenery. Hubley was upset by the film's inaccuracy, stating that "it was not scientifically accurate in terms of the demise of the reptiles. It was more likely they were frozen by the ice age. But Disney didn't want an ice age; he wanted a desert sequence". Hubley also painted several backgrounds for the "Sorcerer's Apprentice" segment. This same year, Hubley moved out of the Woodruffs' house to his own house at 3827 Ronda Vista Place in Los Angeles. Hubley lived here with fellow Disney Studios artist and actor John McLeish.

In the spring of 1941, employees at Disney Studios were unhappy with salary inequalities and the studio discouraging unionization. Hubley and his wife Claudia both participated in the 1941 Disney animators' strike, with John taking dozens of photographs to document the event. Hubley was one of the better-paid employees of the studio, making $67.50 a week (equivalent to $1,367.04 in 2023), but decided to strike in support of unionization. The strike, organized by Hubley's friend Art Babbitt, strengthened Hubley's relationship with strikers like Bill Littlejohn, Herb Klynn, Stephen Bosustow, and Jules Engel, all of whom later worked with Hubley at UPA or Hubley Studios. On August 10, 1941, John and Claudia were two of the 256 employees fired by the studio when the strike ended.

Enlistment and Beginning of UPA: 1942–1948
After being fired from Disney Studios, Hubley briefly worked at Columbia's Screen Gems under Dave Fleischer. Hubley called Fleischer one of "one of the world's intellectual lightweights". Hubley disliked his work at Screen Gems, but Fleischer's detachment from the employees allowed Hubley a creative freedom he had not found at the Disney Studio. On November 23, 1942, Hubley enlisted in the United States Armed Forces to work in the First Motion Picture Unit, an independent film production unit in the Air Force. Here, Hubley directed animated training films related to flight safety and firearm equipment. Though uncredited, Old Blackout Joe (1942) was Hubley's first time directing. Hubley's time in the Air Force was leisurely, and he "got to go home every night" and "spent half [his] time drawing [gags] and passing them around". The Air Force had few expectations for how the films should aesthetically look or feel, allowing Hubley and his team near-complete creative control. Hubley, who had grown increasingly more interested in the works of modern artists like Paul Klee, pushed his films to have flat, abstract visuals. Since the films were often uncredited, it is unknown how many films Hubley directed for the First Motion Picture Unit, but Flight Safety: Landing Accidents (1946) was likely his last. Hubley is credited with the animations on Tuesday in November (1945), produced by the US Office of War Information.

In 1943, Hubley was contacted by the United Automobile Workers (UAW), who were looking to hire Hubley to produce a short film endorsing Franklin D. Roosevelt in the 1944 Presidential Election. Hubley took the project to the newly-formed Industrial Film and Poster Service, which was soon renamed to United Productions of America (UPA). The film, Hell-Bent for Election (1944), was storyboarded by Hubley and directed by Chuck Jones. At UPA, Hubley found the creative freedom he had yearned for his entire career. The UAW was pleased with Hell-Bent for Election and hired UPA for The Brotherhood of Man (1946), a film on race relations. Hubley co-wrote the film and led the production design. With both UAW films, Hubley pushed for a modernist aesthetic of sleek lines, flat shapes, and bold colors that were completely unique to UPA's films.

By 1947, Hubley had been promoted to vice president and creative head of UPA. That same year, UPA founder Stephen Bosustow struck a distribution deal with Columbia: UPA would produce several "trial" films for the studio using Columbia's cartoon stars The Fox and The Crow. If the films were a success, Columbia would enter a formal distribution partnership with UPA. Hubley was tasked with directing the first "trial" films, Robin Hoodlum (1948) and The Magic Fluke (1949).

UPA and Mr. Magoo: 1949–1952
Hubley and the UPA team felt restricted with The Fox and The Crow shorts, and approached Columbia with an idea for an original short. Hubley, inspired by his uncle Harry Woodruff, pitched an idea for a short-tempered, aggressive old curmudgeon. "The character was based upon an uncle of mine, Harry Woodruff" he later said. Hubley and writer Millard Kaufman would name the character Mr. Magoo after Point Mugu in Malibu, California. While Hubley is often credited as the sole creator of Mr. Magoo, the character was a combined effort with Kaufman, who based Magoo partially on his own uncle.

Hubley and UPA founder Zachary Schwartz made their intentions with UPA clear in a 1946 issue of Film Quarterly. Hubley and Schwartz believed it had become "necessary for the craftsman-animators of the motion picture industry to analyze and reevaluate their medium". Hubley and Schwartz were influenced by their shared experience in the First Motion Picture Unit making training films, specifically by how animation was being used as an educational tool, as the two believed "animation usage in the educational film [was] singularly undeveloped" before the war. Now, Hubley and Schwartz understood the "significance of the animated film as means of communication" and aimed to create films that could "express the essence of an idea" with "line, shape, color, and symbols".

Hubley served as the supervising director of Gerald McBoing-Boing (1950), written by Theodor Geisel and directed by Robert Cannon. The film won UPA their first Academy Award for Best Short Subject Cartoon, which "stung" and "really shocked" Hubley, claimed layout artist Bill Hurtz. Hubley, now determined to win his own Academy Award for the studio, directed Rooty Toot Toot (1952), UPA's most expensive and ambitious film at the time. Hubley wrote the film alongside Bill Scott and hired Phil Moore to compose the score. At the recommendation of Art Babbitt, Hubley hired dancer Olga Lunick to choreograph the film's dance elements, and much of the film's animation was done by Betty Boop creator Grim Natwick. The film's dark themes of murder, sex, violence, jealousy, and infidelity were a "groundbreaking moment for animation". While the film was nominated for the Academy Award, it lost to The Two Mouseketeers. The same year, Hubley also directed the animated segments of Irving Reis's The Four Poster (1952).

In September 1951, UPA layout artist Bernyce Fleury testified before the House Un-American Activities Committee that several UPA artists, including Hubley, were promoting communism through their films. In response, the following April Columbia sent UPA a list of eight suspected communist employees which included Hubley. Columbia, threatening to end their distribution deal with UPA, wanted the named employees to either confess or leave UPA. Hubley refused to denounce communism and was subsequently fired from UPA on May 31, 1952. Reflecting upon his time at UPA, Hubley would say "it got too large. Before we knew where we were, we were getting more and more concerned with administration and less with creation."

Independent success with Storyboard, Inc. 1952–1969
Following his firing from UPA, Hubley was effectively blacklisted from the animation industry. He found work illustrating album covers for Westminster and Clef Records for artists such as Al Hibbler, Aaron Copland, Slim Gaillard, and Chico O'Farrill. These covers showed Hubley's art progressing further into abstract expressionism and modernism, taking heavy influence from Pablo Picasso.

Still "undercover" in Hollywood, Hubley founded Storyboard, Inc. (sometimes referred to as Storyboard Studios or simply Storyboard) in 1953. Since television work was both uncredited and in high demand, Hubley quickly found work directing animated commercials for companies such as Heinz, Bank of America, and E-Z Pop. Since many of his clients were looking for a fast turnaround, Hubley's highly-stylized approach to limited animation and bold graphics became both practical and popular. For these early commercials, Hubley would again collaborate with animators such as Bill Littlejohn, Emery Hawkins, and Rob Scribner. Also in 1953, Hubley and producer Michael Shore began developing an animated adaptation of the musical Finian's Rainbow. Shore wanted Hubley to direct, and Hubley was motivated to "develop the visual art even further than the UPA films". Shore had difficulty interesting studios with the project due to the musical's strong racial themes, but eventually secured funding and a distribution deal with the Distributors Corporation of America (DCA). Frank Sinatra and Ella Fitzgerald were signed on for the film, marking their only collaboration. By the end of 1954, all of the dialogue and music had been recorded for the film and Hubley had assembled a large team of past collaborators, such as Littlejohn, Babbitt, and Les Goldman. Faith Elliott (née Chestman), later Hubley's second wife, served as a script supervisor on the film. While Hubley was very excited for the project, his "easygoing manner" made him "hard to work with because he wasn't very disciplined". The musical's writers, Burton Lane and Yip Harburg (a fellow victim of the blacklist), kept a close watch on Hubley, and tensions soon arose over the musical direction of the film and Hubley's visuals. Issues also arose between DCA and members of the film's crew who were members of the Screen Cartoonists Guild (SCG) and not the International Alliance of Theatrical Stage Employees (IATSE). DCA was concerned that since many members of the crew were not IATSE, the film would not be played in theaters. Soon thereafter, DCA president Fred J. Schwartz received a call from IATSE representative Roy Brewer, who ousted Hubley for his refusal to cooperate with the HUAC. Hubley, who still refused to testify before the HUAC, caused DCA's parent company to stop funding the film. While Schwartz did attempt to save the film by approaching RKO, it was no use. The film was canceled in 1955, with the contents of the entire studio impounded.

In 1955, after the collapse of Finian's Rainbow, Hubley moved Storyboard, Inc. with him to New York City, where he soon married his second wife, Faith Hubley (née Chestman). Faith, herself an editor and script supervisor on films such as 12 Angry Men (1957), collaborated closely with her husband on all of their subsequent films. Towards the end of 1954, Hubley and James J. Sweeney, the director of the Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum, began discussing the museum commissioning a film from Hubley. Hubley and Sweeney were determined to create a film that also served as a piece of modern art and communicated the importance of "play" and "the sensuous pleasures of [approaching pictures through] the eye rather than [the] intellectual pleasure [of] the ear". The resulting film, The Adventures of * (1957) was the first short film Hubley directed after leaving UPA, as well as the first animated film ever commissioned by an art museum. The film's visuals were heavily influenced by the Guggenheim Museum's collection of modern art, as well as Hubley's desire to "transform [animation] from hard-lined cel animation to textured, subtle, new styles more connected to the history of art than to the Disney or UPA look". Benny Carter composed the film's score, including vibraphone by Lionel Hampton. The film won several awards, including a diploma speciale from the 1957 Venice Film Festival and the Grand Prize at the 1958 Montevideo Film Festival. In 1957, Hubley was also hired by the advertising firm Fletcher, Richards, Calkins & Holden to direct the hugely successful "I Want My Maypo!" commercial. For the first time in his career, Hubley used the voice of one of his children, his stepson Mark, for the commercial. The commercial led to a boom of sales for Maypo, and the character of "Marky Maypo" (named after his stepson) became the cereal's mascot. The commercial is also credited for beginning the trend of using animation to sell products to children, as it "exploit[ed] children's less than fully developed ability to distinguish between entertainment and selling". Around this time, Hubley met musician Dizzy Gillespie through mutual friend Paul Robeson, and the Hubleys soon made their first film with Gillespie, A Date with Dizzy (1956). The film contained many of the advertisements Hubley had already made at Storyboard, Inc., as well as an original segment by a then-unknown R.O. Blechman.

Following the success of the Maypo spot, John and Faith turned their attention to producing more short films. Their next film, Harlem Wednesday (1957), marked the first time John and Faith were credited alongside one another on-screen (though Faith is credited as Faith Elliott). The film, an experimental montage of paintings by Gregorio Prestopino with a score by Carter, further explored the Hubleys' desires to push animation towards modern art. Their next film, Tender Game (1958), included an unused track by Fitzgerald from Finian's Rainbow. Hubley experimented with multiple exposure effects on the film to give it a distinct look and dimensionality. Mark Hubley would later remark "the film has always struck me...as a love letter between [John and Faith], the figures...look like mom and dad". The film won the grand prize at both the Venice Film Festival and the Montevideo Film Festival. Hubley was inspired by his earlier work on the Mr. Magoo films with Jim Backus to experiment with films centered around improvised dialogue, as he often encouraged Backus to riff in the studio. In 1958, Hubley recorded his sons Mark (aged 6) and Ray (aged 3) his sons playing a game where they search for a "Moonbird", referring to a pet bird the family had lost recently by leaving a window open. Faith edited the conversations together into a narrative, and John enlisted Ed Smith and former UPA director Robert Cannon for animation. The resulting film, Moonbird (1959), marked one of the earliest examples of using real children voices in an animated film. Moonbird won the Academy Award for Best Animated Short in 1960, becoming the first independent film to win in the category. The success of Moonbird caught the attention of Susan Burnett, the film officer of the United Nations Children's Fund (UNICEF), who commissioned the Hubleys to make a film for UNICEF. For the first time, Hubley used the voices of all of he and Faith's children, though most of their vocals are gurgles and mumbles made by his infant daughters Emily and Georgia. The film, Children of the Sun (1960), addressed "how hunger affects the world's children".

Hubley wanted to make a film about Albert Einstein's Theory of Relativity, and was inspired after reading Harlow Shapley's Of Stars and Men (1959) in 1959. Intrigued by Shapley's attempts to understand mankind's place in the universe, Hubley wrote to Shapley with the idea to adapt the book's themes into an animated film. Instead of simply writing a script and getting Shapley's approval, Hubley and Shapley chose to collaborate closely on nearly every aspect of the film, with Hubley sending Shapley detailed outlines for the film's structure and frequently traveling to Shapley's home in Peterborough, New Hampshire, to meet with him. Hubley and Shapley became close friends during this period, resulting in Of Stars and Men (1962), the Hubleys' first feature-length film. The film follows a very loose narrative style, relying predominantly on Shapley's narration. Hubley's children would again appear in the film, with their improvised conversations again being presented much in the same way as in Moonbird. Due to the nature of the film's presentation, the Hubleys, audiences, and distributors alike were unsure if the film could be categorized as a documentary. At the 1961 San Francisco International Film Festival, the film won Best Documentary, and at the Venice Film Festival - where the Hubleys' films had been previously screened as part of the animation category - the film was placed in the feature category alongside live-action films. Author Sybil DelGaudio cites the film as one of the earliest examples of an animated documentary. While the film was screened in festivals as early as 1962, the Hubleys would continue to revise the film and appeal to both Columbia and Show Corp. for distribution; it would be released to the general public in 1964 by Films, Inc.

While shopping around Of Stars and Men, the Hubleys collaborated again with Gillespie for The Hole (1962). Gillespie and actor George Matthews improvised a conversation between two construction workers discussing life and nuclear war. The film mirrored American anxieties over the Cold War, as it was in production during the Cuban Missile Crisis. The film won the Hubleys their second Academy Award for Best Animated Short, with John and Faith both being recognized by the Academy for the first time. The Hole led to the World Law Foundation commissioning the Hubleys to make The Hat (1964), a spiritual successor of sorts to The Hole centered around an improvised conversation between Gillespie and Dudley Moore as soldiers debating the morality of war. The Hat came from the World Law Foundation's initiative to "reach...broader audiences" through "arts and media". Both The Hole and The Hat use a more grounded visual style than the abstract expressionism of The Adventures of * and Of Stars and Men and address more serious themes of violence, nuclear war, nuclear anxieties, and death. The Hat was the only film by the Hubleys distributed by McGraw-Hill, and was also released as a book with illustrations taken from the film. Carter would collaborate with the Hubleys again on Urbanissimo (1966), a film humorously examining the impact of urban sprawl on the environment made for Expo 67 in Montreal, Quebec. A Herb Alpert and the Tijuana Brass Double Feature (1966), a film interpreting the music of jazz musician Herb Alpert, was released the same year. John and Faith won their third Academy Award for the short, and the film is today considered to be an early prototypical example of a music video. The film was distributed by Paramount, marking the first collaboration between Hubley and a major Hollywood studio following his 1952 blacklisting.

Hubley began teaching filmmaking at Harvard in 1962, becoming the first teacher of animation at Harvard's Visual Arts Center. Hubley wrote an adaptation of Edwin Abbot's 1884 novella Flatland, and collaborated with his students as well as Dudley Moore and several members of Beyond the Fringe. The resulting film, Flatland (1965), was directed by Eric Martin. As early as 1964, filmmaker Joseph Koenig pitched a film explaining the importance of voting to the National Film Board of Canada (NFB). Hubley was chosen to direct the film for the NFB, which eventually became The Cruise (1967). The film was designed to be an educational tool for school use, though Hubley had very little involvement with creating the curriculum surrounding the film. The film would be screened in high schools and colleges across the United States and Canada throughout the 1960s and 1970s. Hubley's involvement with education would continue in the 1970s, when he and Faith became professors of film at Yale University teaching animation and "The Visualization of Abstract Themes".

The Hubleys continued to make short films together for the rest of the 1960s. Their next film, Windy Day (1967) featured an improvised conversation between their daughters Georgia and Emily "explor[ing] the child's projection of fantasy to enact romance, marriage, and growing up". The film was nominated for the 1968 Academy Award for Best Animated Short, but lost to Disney's Winnie the Pooh and the Blustery Day. The Center for the Study of Democratic Institutions commissioned Hubley for Zuckerkandl! (1968), a short film interpreting a comical routine by Robert M. Hutchins. The short was also released as a book with illustrations by Hubley. Hubley was commissioned again for Storyboard, Inc.'s next film, Of Men and Demons (1969), by IBM for Expo '70 in Osaka, Japan. The film earned John and Faith their fifth Academy Award nomination for Best Animated Short.

Hubley Studios, Inc. and Late Career: 1970–1977
1970 saw the release of Hubley's fifteenth independent directorial credit with Eggs (1970). For the first time, John and Faith collaborated with musician Quincy Jones, who composed and performed the film's score. The film addressed themes of fertility and death and continues Hubley's run of collaborating with musicians as voice actors, as singers Anita Ellis and Grady Tate lent their voices for the film, as did actor David Burns. The film was entirely animated by Tissa David, a recent hire of the Hubleys best known as the second woman to ever direct a feature-length animated film, Bonjour Paris! (1953). Around this time, Storyboard, Inc. was renamed Hubley Studios, Inc. (sometimes referred to as The Hubley Studio or Hubley Studios), indicating Hubley's growing confidence towards using his name as the effects of the blacklist faded away.

Despite the critical acclaim the studio's films received, Hubley was still struggling financially. "Film shorts seem inevitably to be financial failures, for the only people who come out ahead on them are the distributors. Even Moonbird, for instance, grossed at least as much as its production costs (about $25,000), but only a third of the gross wound up at Storyboard, Inc.", revealed a 1964 profile by The Harvard Crimson. By the beginning of the 1970s, John and Faith understood they needed to take on more commercial work in order to fund their shorts, and began contributing animated segments for New York-based children's variety programs such as The Electric Company and Sesame Street. Notably, Hubley directed the "Letter E" segment for the latter's first episode on November 10, 1969. Hubley directed over thirty animated segments for the show between 1969 and 1977. His most notable contributions would be on The Electric Company, where Hubley directed "The Adventures of Letterman" segments from 1972 to 1977 featuring Joan Rivers, Gene Wilder, and Zero Mostel. On both Sesame Street and The Electric Company Hubley would again collaborate with artists like Quincy Jones and Dizzy Gillespie for voice acting and music. To help handle the new workload at the studio, Hubley hired several new artists, including Tissa David and Michael Sporn.

While working on animated segments for Sesame Street and The Electric Company, Hubley became more recognized for his television work (as he hadn't made a television commercial since the late 1950s). CBS approached the Hubleys to produce an educational program on geology for the station. Hubley enlisted the help of geoscientist Bruce Heezen to research the film. Originally titled "What's Under My Foot?", Dig (1972) premiered on CBS on April 8, 1972. The film's music was composed by Jones and featured Jack Warden and Hubley's son, Ray. The following year, the film was adapted into a book co-written by John and Faith. Much in the same way The Hole and The Hat were companion pieces, Hubley's next film, Cockaboody (1973) was a companion piece to Windy Day (1967). Hubley again recorded a conversation between his daughters Georgia and Emily and brought it to life through animation. Unlike Windy Day, John and Faith collaborated with students in their animation class at Yale University to create the film. Cockaboody was created in conjunction with the Hubleys' students at Yale, as well as the Yale Child Study Center. The process of making Cockaboody at Yale was filmed by Howard Sayre Weaver for the documentary In Quest of Cockaboody (1973). Cockaboody marked the first time The Hubley Studio name was used in one of Hubley's films, and the second film at the studio animated solely by David.

John and Faith earned another Academy Award nomination for their next shot, Voyage to the Next (1974), another collaboration with Gillespie, as well as actresses Maureen Stapleton and Dee Dee Bridgewater commissioned by The Institute for World Order. Continuing the themes of previous films like Eggs and The Hat, Voyage to the Next tackles themes of environmentalism, nationalism, and war. The same year, the Zagreb Film Festival held a career-long retrospective on John and Faith's films, with John serving as president of the year's jury. In an ironic turn of events, Hubley's next film, People People People (1975), was commissioned by the United States Bicentennial Commission. Hubley, now being commissioned by the same government that had practically forced him out of UPA in 1952, was finally free from the effects of the blacklist. This same year, both John and Faith were awarded the Winsor McCay Award from ASIFA, the highest honor an artist in the animation industry can receive.

Now one of the most respected artists in an industry that had blacklisted him only two decades prior, Hubley began his most ambitious project to date. As early as 1973, John and Faith became interested in adapting Erik Erikson's Theory of the Eight Stages of Life in a feature-length animated film. As they did with Cockaboody, the Hubleys planned to make the film in conjunction with Yale's Film Laboratory Center. Initially, Erikson was dismissive of the idea, but by 1975 he agreed, with CBS interested in airing the film. Initially, CBS and Hubley agreed the film would be three half-hour episodes, but CBS changed it to be one ninety-minute film during the final three months of production. John and Faith created the film's storyboards alongside their Yale class, supervised by professor Ken Kennison. Hubley picked many unknown actors with few or no prior credits for the film, including Lawrence Pressman, his then-girlfriend Lanna Saunders, and Yale student Meryl Streep in her first acting role. The Hubley children also appear in the film for different stages of life. Everybody Rides the Carousel (1976) was broadcast on September 10, 1976. Much like the Hubleys' previous films, the film is built from improvised conversations between the actors relating to Erikson's stages of life. The larger production led to Hubley Studios hiring a handful of new employees, including Erikson's daughter, Sue Erikson, coincidentally a student of the Hubleys at Yale. The film was a success, and won the Blue Ribbon Award at that year's American Film Festival.

Around the time Hubley began production on Everybody Rides the Carousel, producer Martin Rosen hired Hubley to direct an animated adaptation of Richard Adams' Watership Down (1972). Hubley flew to London to meet Rosen at the new studio Rosen opened for the film and the two took trips to the English countryside for inspiration, but Hubley's interest in the project quickly faded. Rosen and Hubley frequently disagreed on the film's narrative, with Rosen pushing for grittiness and Hubley pushing for a lighter tone and more abstract visual style. Hubley had signed an exclusivity contract to work on the film, but Rosen soon found out he was secretly developing a new film, leading to Rosen firing Hubley from the film and becoming the director himself. Hubley's work can be seen in the opening "fable" scene, animated by Bill Littlejohn, Phil Duncan, Ruth Kissane, and Barrie Nelson. Hubley is often credited as the co-director of the film, but his name does not appear in the credits. In November 1976, cartoonist Garry Trudeau approached Hubley with the idea of an animated special featuring Trudeau's characters from Doonesbury. Hubley and Trudeau had already known one another, as Trudeau was one of Hubley's students in the early seventies, and Trudeau and the Hubleys greatly enjoyed working with one another. In 1976, Doonesbury was one of the most popular newspaper comics in America, having won a Pulitzer Prize the year prior and frequently making headlines for being dropped by papers across the country over Trudeau's decision to tackle topical and controversial real-world events. Unlike their previous films, John and Faith shared directing and producing credits with Trudeau and followed a tight script for the film. Toward the middle of production in February 1977 Hubley died, leaving Faith and Trudeau to finish the film themselves. A Doonesbury Special (1977) was broadcast on NBC on November 27, 1977. The film earned Hubley a posthumous Academy Award Nomination  and posthumous Special Jury Prize at the Cannes Film Festival, tying with Oh, My Darling by Dutch animator Børge Ring.

Personal life
On May 30, 1941, Hubley married Claudia Sewell, one of Disney's "ink and paint girls", in Reno, Nevada. The couple did not go on a honeymoon, and instead sped back to California to partake in the 1941 animator's strike, which had started the day prior. The Hubleys moved to a house at 10543 Woodbridge Street in the Toluca Lake section of Los Angeles. The couple's first child, Anne, was born in 1942. John and Claudia had two more children, Mark and Susan, while living at 11689 Laurelwood Drive in Los Angeles. Both houses were only a short drive from the UPA studio in Burbank.

Sometime in the 1940s, Hubley met Faith Elliott, a stage manager from New York City who had come to Los Angeles to become a script clerk at Columbia. Faith recalled she "met John in Hollywood...when he was in the Army". The two became friends and remained friends during Hubley's time at UPA. When Hubley was fired from UPA and began work on Finian's Rainbow, Yip Harburg assigned Elliott to be Hubley's assistant. By all accounts, the relationship between Hubley and Elliott was platonic, with Elliott saying they "both... controlled their friendship for ten years and after all [Hubley] was a married man with three children". Nonetheless, as Elliott and Hubley grew closer, Hubley's own marriage crumbled. John and Claudia divorced in 1954, with his children staying in Los Angeles while Hubley left to focus on Storyboard, Inc. in New York City.

Hubley married Elliott in 1955. Faith Elliott was born Faith Chestman in 1924, but kept the name of her first husband, Melvin Elliott, a radio announcer on WQXR. Faith already had one child, Mark, born in 1952. When the Hubleys married, they vowed to make one film a year together, and to have dinner with their family every night. The Hubleys moved to the Upper West Side of New York City at 110 Riverside Drive, and had three more children: Raymond, Emily, and Georgia. All of the Hubley's children would voice characters in their films, with Mark and Ray appearing in Moonbird and Dig, and Emily and Georgia appearing in Windy Day and Cockaboody. All four are featured in Everybody Rides the Carousel. Raymond Hubley later remembered "there were a lot of enforced things...in our family that [were] connected to the work regiment of [John and Faith's] relationship...they used to have a thing where we'd go around the table and tell [about] your day, and it was like a pitch meeting or something". Many of Hubleys kids went on to pursue their own artistic careers, with Raymond becoming a film editor, Emily becoming an animator, and Georgia founding the band Yo La Tengo with her husband Ira Kaplan. Given the nature of John and Faith's collaboration, Faith was sometimes looked over professionally with the attention and credit for their films given to her husband. Hubley actively fought against this, highlighting Faith's contributions and their collaboration whenever possible. Following Hubley's solo Academy Award win for Moonbird, he and Faith would be nominated together for the rest of their career. In his final interview before his death, Hubley insisted interviewer Michael Barrier was "sure to write [the article] in terms of the partnership of me and Faith, because all of the films, right from the beginning of our stuff, from Guggenheim on up, have always been a very close collaboration, creatively and on every other level."

Hubley remained close with a number of UPA and Disney animators, many of whom he worked with on Storyboard, Inc. films. The Hubleys also became close friends with musician Dizzy Gillespie in the 1950s, meeting through mutual friend Paul Robeson. Gillespie made several films with Storyboard, Inc., including the Academy Award-winning The Hole. Gillespie "respect[ed] them and appreciate[d] their creativity", calling them "wonderful people, very warm and very generous" who "seem[ed] to see me in things other people don't see". Gillespie was a constant presence around the Hubley's house, with Mark Hubley remembering John and Faith "having parties [with Gillespie]" often, and Gillespie once "standing on his head playing 'Happy Birthday'" for Raymond. Hubley was also close with Benny Carter and Quincy Jones.

Political views and HUAC investigation
Hubley was a lifelong registered Democrat. In 1951, the House Un-American Activities Committee (HUAC) heard the testimony of UPA layout artist Bernyce Fleury, who claimed Hubley's films promoted communism and Hubley held communist sympathies. On April 25, 1952, Hubley was formally subpoenaed by the HUAC to appear at the Los Angeles Federal Building for questioning. The subpoena was served to Hubley's attorney on May 2. While Hubley did leave UPA, he did not respond to the subpoena, and on February 2, 1953, Hubley was again summoned to the Federal Building for questioning. Boyle found that Hubley had moved in the year prior before receiving the subpoena, hence his lack of response. For an unknown reason, Hubley was not subpoenaed again until May 4, 1955, to appear before the HUAC. Hubley responded, and was set to appear before the HUAC on June 20, 1956. Hubley's attorney, Arthur McNulty, postponed the hearing twice, first until June 28, then to July 5, likely since Hubley had already moved to New York City.

On July 5, 1956, Hubley appeared before the HUAC in Room 227 of the Los Angeles Federal Building with McNulty as his counsel. California Representatives Clyde Doyle and Donald L. Jackson presided over the hearing. When asked if he held communist sympathies, Hubley responded "I feel that in the area of politics...I do not feel personally that your committee should ask me to reveal or speak on these matters, either with my opinions or associations...I do not agree it is a proper question for a person such as myself to be asked". Hubley invoked the Fifth Amendment for the remainder of the hearing. When asked if his films at UPA promoted communist ideas, Hubley replied: "I have a lot of opinions on art...It is public work, and anyone is welcome to examine it and to look at it, and I stand on my work, and not on my opinions. My opinions can change, and I have changed them many times, all through my life, and I like the right we have to be able to change them. But the work stands. I have no shame about it. If anyone wants to examine it, it is there...My work has been my own work, and my own talent, and my own opinions."

Hubley was never formally indicted by the HUAC, but the investigation did effectively blacklist him from Hollywood afterwards. He named his new studio Storyboard, Inc. out of fear of using his own name.

Style and technique
While at UPA, Hubley's films were more flat and graphic than those of Disney Studios or Warner Bros. Cartoons. Hubley was greatly influenced by Ivan Ivanov-Vano's The Tale of Czar Durandai (1934), which used limited animation and flat compositions to create an incredibly stylized world. While Hubley's early UPA films featuring The Fox and the Crow animate the main characters in a style similar to that of Disney Studios, the films' backgrounds showcase Hubley's influence from European design. Punchy De Leon opens with a panning shot of a highly-stylized graphic background that uses skewed perspective, large blocks of color, and exaggerated shape language. Hints of Hubley's stylization of background perspectives and crows shots can also be seen in Robin Hoodlum and The Magic Fluke.

After UPA finished its trial run with Columbia in 1950, Hubley's films became more visually ambitious. As the supervising director of Gerald McBoing-Boing, Hubley oversaw the film's unique visuals provided by designer Bill Hurtz and colorists Herb Klynn and Jules Engel. Rooty Toot Toot uses complex color blocking to tell its story visually, and implements even stronger skewed perspective and stylized line art backgrounds. Unlike Gerald Mc-Boing Boing, which uses abstract blocks of color in its backgrounds, Rooty Toot Toot experimented with different patterns and brush types. The film's last act is illustrated in the style of sponge painting, pulling inspiration from European abstract expressionist artists. This push towards replicating brush strokes and printmaking in backgrounds extended to the animated segments Hubley directed for The Four Poster. For his independent directorial debut, The Adventures of *, Hubley drew heavily from the visual style of artists like Paul Klee, Joan Miró, and Pablo Picasso. The film's backgrounds were painted with sponges and thick brushes for texture. The characters were drawn in yellow crayon on black paper to give them a more unique, handmade look. In subsequent films, Hubley would experiment with watercolors, ballpoint pen, and fabric markers to give his films distinctive visuals. Hubley used both cels and the Xerox method (popularized by Ub Iwerks on the 1961 film One Hundred and One Dalmatians) depending on the film. For Cockaboody, characters were drawn on paper by Tissa David, then cut out and placed on cels. Hubley sometimes opted to use underlighting - wherein the drawing or cel is lit from below rather than above - to make the films more distinct, and often used multiple exposure for more complex elements, like the river in Tender Game or the abstract color section in Everybody Rides the Carousel.

While directing The Ragtime Bear, Hubley encouraged actor Jim Backus to improvise his dialogue and ramble on as his character Mr. Magoo would. Bauckus' unique vocal performance would make Mr. Magoo a hit, becoming UPA's flagship character. The idea of using improvised dialogue in animation was not created by Hubley, as Dave Fleischer often encouraged his actors to make up their own dialogue for his Popeye and Betty Boop shorts, but the success of Bauckus as Mr. Magoo inspired Hubley to pursue stream of consciousness improvisation for his independent films. Hubley took the idea a step further by recording his children playing together, interpreting their conversations through animation after Faith had edited them together into a story. Films like The Hat, The Hole, and Everybody Rides the Carousel consist entirely of improvised conversations between actors, and Zuckerlandl! is an animated interpretation of a comedy routine by Robert M. Hutchins.

Many of Hubley's films at Storyboard, Inc. with his wife explore war and the nature of conflict. The Hat, The Hole, Eggs, Voyage to the Next, and Urbanissimo tackle industrialization, war, overpopulation, and the environment, all subjects the Hubleys were highly concerned with. Hubley, himself an avid reader of psychology books, also looked to explore complex psychological theories in his films, as he believed animation to be the perfect medium to visualize such intricate ideas. Fittingly, the Hubleys taught a class at Yale called "The Visualization of Abstract Themes". Hubley was also fascinated with the way children discussed life and their own experiences, which can be seen in Moonbird, Windy Day, and Cockaboody.

Death, preservation and legacy
During the production of A Doonesbury Special, Hubley went to the Yale New Haven Medical Center for what was thought to be a standard heart procedure. Hubley died during the surgery on February 21, 1977, at the age of 62. A Doonesbury Special was completed by his wife and Garry Trudeau, earning John Hubley a posthumous Academy Award nomination and Palme d'Or win. Hubley was cremated, and his ashes were spread over the Atlantic Ocean.

During his life and after his death, retrospectives and screenings of Hubley's films have been held all over the world. The Museum of Modern Art held a major two-part exhibition on the Hubleys' films and artwork in 1997 and 1998, and the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences held a salute to Hubley in 2011. Mr. Magoo, a character co-created by Hubley, would become one of the most famous cartoon characters of all time, ranking #29 on TV Guide's "50 Greatest Cartoon Characters of All Time" list in 2002. Hubley is often cited as one of the most influential figures in the history of animation, influencing artists such as Michael Sporn, Gene Deitch, and his own daughter, Emily Hubley. On October 2, 2022, Garry Trudeau's Doonesbury ran a strip encouraging readers to watch Hubley's Windy Day.

Eight of Hubley's films (Moonbird, The Hole, A Herb Alpert & The Tijuana Brass Double Feature, Windy Day, Of Men and Demons, Voyage to the Next, A Doonesbury Special, and A Smattering of Spots - a reel of Storyboard, Inc. commercials) are preserved in the Academy Film Archive. Papers from Hubley's life are held at the Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum, the Harvard University Library, the Yale University Library, the Museum of Modern Art, and the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences. In 2013, The Hole was selected for preservation in the United States National Film Registry by the Library of Congress for being "culturally, historically, or aesthetically significant". Artwork from Moonbird, Windy Day, Cockaboody, and several other of the Hubleys' films are on display at the Academy Museum of Motion Pictures in Los Angeles.

In 2021, a crowdfunded campaign headed by the Animation Education Association to have a Wisconsin State Historical Marker for Hubley placed in Marinette, Wisconsin, reached its goal. The marker was unveiled on May 20, 2023. To coincide with the unveiling, May 20, 2023, was proclaimed "John and Faith Hubley Day" in Wisconsin by Marinette's mayor Steve Genisot.

Screen Gems

 * Wolf Chases Pigs (1942)
 * Old Blackout Joe (1942)
 * The Dumbconscious Mind (1942)
 * King Midas, Junior (1942)
 * The Vitamin G-Man (1943)
 * Professor Small and Mister Tall (1943)
 * He Can't Make It Stick (1943)

UPA

 * Flat Hatting (1946)
 * Robin Hoodlum (1948)
 * The Magic Fluke (1949)
 * Ragtime Bear (1949)
 * Spellbound Hound (1950)
 * Punchy de Leon (1950)
 * Gerald McBoing-Boing (1951) (Oscar winner)
 * Fuddy Duddy Buddy (1951)
 * Rooty Toot Toot (1952)

Format Films

 * The Tale of Old Whiff (1959)

Storyboard/Hubley Studios

 * A Date with Dizzy (1956)
 * Adventures of * (1957)
 * Harlem Wednesday (1957)
 * Tender Game (1958)
 * Moonbird (1959) (Oscar winner)
 * Children of the Sun (1960)
 * Of Stars and Men (1962)
 * The Hole (1962) (Oscar winner)
 * The Hat (1964)
 * Fail-Safe (1964)
 * A Herb Alpert and the Tijuana Brass Double Feature (1966) (Oscar winner)
 * Urbanissimo (1966)
 * The Cruise  (1967)
 * Windy Day (1968) (Oscar nominee)
 * Zuckerkandl! (1968)
 * Of Men and Demons (1969) (Oscar nominee)
 * Eggs (1970)
 * Dig (1972)
 * Cockaboody (1973)
 * Voyage to Next (1974) (Oscar nominee)
 * People, People, People (1975)
 * Everybody Rides the Carousel (1976)
 * A Doonesbury Special (1977) (Oscar nominee)
 * Watership Down (1978) (uncredited)
 * The Cosmic Eye (1986) (archive footage)

TV
 * Sesame Street ("Imagination E", 1969)
 * Sesame Street ("O Song", 1969)
 * Sesame Street ("Polar Bear & Exit", 1970)
 * Sesame Street ("Small V", 1970)
 * Sesame Street ("F for Football", 1971)
 * Sesame Street ("Baby Fantasy", 1971)
 * Sesame Street ("Birds 1-20", 1971)
 * Sesame Street ("Penguin Rhythms", 1971)
 * Sesame Street ("Hungry M", 1971)
 * Sesame Street ("Letter S", 1972)
 * The Electric Company ("The Adventures of Letterman", 1972)

title: John Hubley


text:
User talk:JFrog

Hello and welcome to Wikipedia! Hope you like it here, and stick around.

Here are some tips to help you get started:

 * To sign your posts (on talk pages, for example) use the '~' symbol. To insert just your name, type ~~~ (3 tildes), or, to insert your name and timestamp, use ~~~~ (4 tildes).
 * Try the Tutorial, and feel free to experiment in the test area.
 * If you need help, post a question at the Help Desk
 * Eventually, you might want to read the Manual of Style and Policies and Guidelines.
 * Remember Neutral point of view
 * Explore, be bold in editing pages, and, most importantly, have fun!

Good luck!

147.9.159.128 02:28, 20 Dec 2004 (UTC)

license: Creative Commons - Attribution Share-Alike - https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/

title: User talk:JFrog


text:
Talk:Robert Thomson (executive)

Mistake
I think i may have made a mistake in the move and editing, I am under the imprestion that its Robert William Thomson and not Robert Thomson. Joel M. 02:28, Dec 20, 2004 (UTC)

This person apparently emailed Jimbo to complain the title was wrong and that his name was Robert James Thomson, not Robert William Thomson so I've moved the article. Angela. 09:58, September 4, 2005 (UTC)

Addition
I work for Rubenstein and on behalf of Robert Thomson I'd like to add the following sentence to this article:

 * During Thomson's time as editor-in-chief, the Wall Street Journal rose to become #1 in circulation, with more than 2 million readers in 2009.

To mitigate conflict of interest issues, I ask that an editor please review and either give feedback and/or edit accordingly. NinaSpezz (talk) 19:36, 13 April 2017 (UTC)
 * Number 1 in what sort of category?? Nomoskedasticity (talk) 18:45, 21 April 2017 (UTC)
 * After the paragraph that ends with "...The Times became 100% compact." in order to keep the Biography section in chronological order. NinaSpezz (talk) 18:52, 21 April 2017 (UTC)
 * Declining as page is currently under a copyright investigation. jd22292 (Jalen D. Folf) (talk) 00:52, 1 August 2017 (UTC)
 * If you would like to license the content, see Donating_copyrighted_materials - Yuhong (talk) 09:15, 11 August 2017 (UTC)
 * The copyright investigation has concluded and the change has been implemented in the same paragraph. jd22292 (Jalen D. Folf) (talk) 21:45, 18 August 2017 (UTC)

Copyright violations
Currently, the article has a 58% confidence rating on the Copyvios check for the link shown on the template. Please comply the instructions and do not remove the template until the situation has been resolved. jd22292 (Jalen D. Folf) (talk) 03:37, 1 August 2017 (UTC)

Additions
I work for Rubenstein and on behalf of Robert Thomson, I'd like to propose the following updates and additions to the article. To mitigate conflict of interest issues, I ask that an editor please review and either give feedback and/or edit accordingly. NinaSpezz (talk) 15:00, 25 May 2018 (UTC)

 * Add back middle name - Thomson's full name is Robert James Dell'Oro Thomson. Dell'Oro was removed as could not be verified. However, this article includes full name.

 * Relocate 1st sentence in "Biography" section to an "Early life and education" section to bring section headings more in line with typical BLP layout.

 * Rename "Biography" section to "Career"

 * Create "Personal life" section" and relocate sentence beginning with "Thomson is married to Wang Ping..." to that section.

 * Add to the beginning of Career section:

Thomson began his journalistic career as a copyboy at The Herald in Melbourne (now the Herald Sun), working his way up the ranks. At the age of 24, he became the Beijing correspondent for the Financial Times and The Sydney Morning Herald, and four years later moved to Tokyo as a correspondent for the Financial Times. He was the FT's Foreign News Editor in 1994, and in 1996 became editor of the Weekend FT. He later oversaw the launch of How To Spend It magazine and the Weekend FT became the fastest growing paper in the UK market.

In 1998, Thomson moved to New York City to become the managing editor of the FT's U.S. edition. During his four-year tenure, FT.com was launched in the U.S., and the paper tripled U.S. sales to nearly 150,000.

In 2002, Thomson became editor of London’s The Times, owned by Rupert Murdoch.

 * Add after "Under Thomson, The Times paid more attention to international politics, business, financial markets and sport. In 2003, The Times launched a compact edition alongside the broadsheet format and one year later on 1 November 2004 The Times became 100% compact.":

He launched The Game, a football section and Bricks & Mortar, a property supplement. In addition, he launched Luxx magazine. Under Thomson’s editorship, the monthly audience of The Times Online grew from less than 1 million to nearly 13 million.

After acquiring The Wall Street Journal in 2007, Murdoch appointed Thomson publisher. The following year Thomson would assume the role of managing editor of the Journal and editor-in-chief of the Dow Jones & Company. The Journal's circulation rose to more than 2 million in 2008, making it America’s largest newspaper at a time of an industry-wide decline in circulation.

 * Add after "Robert Thomson was given an honorary doctorate and was a keynote speaker at RMIT University's Dec 2010 graduation.":

Thomson become Chief Executive of News Corp in 2013 when News Corporation officially split and spun off its newspaper and publishing operations into News Corp.

 * Thanks for using the talk-page to request changes, . In the normal way, an edit request of more than a few sentences is unlikely to be accepted; as you will understand, that is partly to encourage COI editors to be concise. To specifics:
 * The source you suggest we use for his additional middle name (a) is a marketing publication (so inherently untrustworthy); (b) is too new to have established any reputation for fact-checking; (c) almost certainly copied his name from us at the same time that it copied his picture. We'd require a solid source clearly and definitively independent of the subject; something like, say, the Library of Congress – which, however, lists him only as "Thomson, Robert", as does every other library. What is our source for the "James"? And while we're at it, what is our source for the date of birth in our article? VIAF gives only the year.
 * As for the rest of your proposed content, I skimmed through it. My eye stopped at this "During his four-year tenure, FT.com was launched in the U.S.,[6] and the paper tripled U.S. sales to nearly 150,000". This is precisely the kind of specious or fallacious argument we are used to seeing in promotional biographies – "x happened while he was there, ergo he brought about x". I accept that the same considerations apply to the unreferenced content about the downgrading of the format of the paper, which I'll remove in a moment.
 * In general, it's probably better to let this page develop in the ordinary Wikipedia way, with unbiased volunteer editors making changes as and when they feel like it. If you insist on trying to interfere with that process, please include request edit (exactly so, with the curly parentheses) in any future request, and please, for pity's sake, make it brief. Thanks, Justlettersandnumbers (talk) 18:32, 25 May 2018 (UTC)

Expand career
I work for Rubenstein and on behalf of Robert Thomson, I'd like to propose the following additions to the article. To mitigate conflict of interest issues, I ask that an editor please review and either give feedback and/or edit accordingly. NinaSpezz (talk) 16:02, 29 May 2018 (UTC)

Following recent edits and feedback on previous request above, breaking request into shorter requests. Would like to rename "Work" section to "Career" and add:

Thomson began his journalistic career as a copyboy at The Herald in Melbourne (now the Herald Sun), working his way up the ranks. At the age of 24, he became the Beijing correspondent for the Financial Times and The Sydney Morning Herald, and four years later moved to Tokyo as a correspondent for the Financial Times. He was the FT's Foreign News Editor in 1994, and in 1996 became editor of the Weekend FT. He later oversaw the launch of How To Spend It magazine and the Weekend FT became the fastest growing paper in the UK market.

In 1998, Thomson moved to New York City to become the managing editor of the FT's U.S. edition. During his four-year tenure, FT.com was launched in the U.S., and the paper tripled U.S. sales to nearly 150,000.

In 2002, Thomson became editor of London’s The Times, owned by Rupert Murdoch.

Reply quote box with inserted reviewer decisions and feedback 29-MAY-2018
Below you will see where text from your request has been quoted with individual advisory messages placed underneath, either accepting, declining or otherwise commenting upon your proposal(s). Please see the enclosed notes for additional information about each request. Also note areas where additional clarification was requested. When this is ready to be provided to the reviewer, please open a new edit request. Thank you!  .  spinten do    17:19, 29 May 2018 (UTC)

Got it. Thanks for your time and attention on this. Could use a bit more clarification on citing of encyclopedias, Encyclopedia Britannica in this case. My understanding according to WP:RSPRIMARY is that encyclopedias, with the exception of Wikipedia, are reputable tertiary sources. And while Wikipedia articles should be based mainly on reliable secondary sources, tertiary sources may be cited. NinaSpezz (talk) 16:09, 30 May 2018 (UTC)
 * Thank you for your reply. Reliable tertiary sources can be helpful in (1) providing broad summaries of topics that involve many primary  and  secondary sources; and also may be helpful in (2) evaluating due weight, especially when primary or secondary sources contradict each other . I don't see either of those situations in the case of the Robert Thomson article, where the sources given are all primary sources. In the four instances from your edit request where you wanted to use an encyclopedia, the nature of the sentence's individual claim statements either prevented this (as in example No. #4, below) or were to be better sourced elsewhere (as in example No's. #1-3, below):

 * 1) "In 2002, Thomson became editor of London’s The Times, owned by Rupert Murdoch."
 * 2) "He was the FT's Foreign News Editor in 1994, and in 1996 became editor of the Weekend FT."
 * 3) "In 1998, Thomson moved to New York City to become the managing editor of the FT's U.S. edition."
 * 4) Claims of employment such as these statements underlined in orange are easily and more reliably sourced by the institutions in question. As the original provider to the subject of payroll, tax information, benefits etc., the employer was and still is the most intimately knowledgeable source on the subject's employment, having access to when the subject started working and for how long and in what positions. The best way to reference these statements would be to have the employer as verification of the actual employment while the encyclopedia is perfectly capable of verifying just the dates of employment.
 * 5) "Thomson began his journalistic career as a copyboy at The Herald in Melbourne (now the Herald Sun), working his way up the ranks."
 * 6) Encyclopedia's are good for dates but this part of the claim statement underlined in red makes a claim as to the subject's proficiency/speed/ability/adaptability at advancing through varying positions of employment, a claim that the encyclopedia would not be expected to have access to, given the tertiary nature of the publication.  spintendo   19:30, 4 June 2018 (UTC)

Revised request
I have revised my previous request based on feedback (above). Please note I work for Rubenstein and on behalf of Robert Thomson, I'm proposing the following additions to the article. To mitigate conflict of interest issues, I ask that an editor please review and either give feedback and/or edit accordingly.

Would like to change "Work" section to "Career" and add the following to the beginning of that section:

Thomson began his journalistic career in 1979 as a copyboy at The Herald in Melbourne (now the Herald Sun). In 1983, he became senior feature writer for the The Sydney Morning Herald and two years later became Beijing correspondent for The Sydney Morning Herald as well as the Financial Times (FT). In 1990, he co-authored The Chinese Army: An Illustrated History from The Long March to Tiananmen Square.

Thomson then relocated to Toyko to become full-time correspondent for the FT. He was appointed FT’s Foreign News Editor in 1994 and in 1996 became editor of FT’s weekend edition, which would become the fasted-growing paper in the UK a year later.

In 1998, Thomson moved to New York to become U.S. managing editor of the FT. Over the next four years, FT.com launched in the U.S., and U.S. sales tripled to nearly 150,000. — Preceding unsigned comment added by NinaSpezz (talk • contribs) 16:34, 22 June 2018 (UTC)

Reply to edit request 23-JUN-2018
Below you will see where text from your request has been quoted with individual advisory messages placed underneath each quote, either accepting, declining or otherwise commenting upon your proposal(s). Please see the enclosed notes at the bottom of the quote box for additional information on each request. It should be noted that much of this information is taken from the following Observer piece: The subject's Wikipedia article ought not to become just a mirror of the information stated in this one reference. If this information was fact checked by the Observer, then it must have come from somewhere. Reporting on these dates of employment from many different organizations is asking too much for this one reference to do. Thus, in areas where additional clarification was requested, please be sure to provide the suggested references from those publications. When this is ready to be provided to the reviewer, please open a new edit request. Thank you!  spintendo   14:05, 23 June 2018 (UTC)

 * I have used a variety of reliable secondary sources to support employment and dates, using the Observer article only for the year on the copyboy position at Sydney Morning Herald (the position itself is also supported by the Britannica citation). The New Yorker, New York Magazine, and Sydney Morning Herald are also used to support other positions and dates, so I'm confused by the implication the Observer article is asked to do all the fact checking on various positions and dates.

 * I am unaware of a Wikipedia content guideline suggesting the employer itself must provide verification for employment and dates for a BLP when several publications known for their fact checking also support positions held and dates in question. And how would the employer provide this verification to Wikipedia? What would be satisfactory here before I open a new request? NinaSpezz (talk) 15:12, 23 June 2018 (UTC)

Reply 26-JUN-2018
Thank you for your reply. I'm happy to go over your proposed text once again to highlight the issue areas.

Proposed text
Thomson began his journalistic career in 1979 as a copyboy at The Herald in Melbourne (now the Herald Sun).[1][2]

In 1983, he became senior feature writer for the The Sydney Morning Herald and two years later became Beijing correspondent for The Sydney Morning Herald as well as the Financial Times (FT).[3]

In 1990, he co-authored The Chinese Army: An Illustrated History from The Long March to Tiananmen Square.[4][5]

Thomson then relocated to Toyko to become full-time correspondent for the FT.

He was appointed FT’s Foreign News Editor in 1994 and in 1996 became editor of FT’s weekend edition, which would become the fasted-growing paper in the UK a year later.[6][3]

In 1998, Thomson moved to New York to become U.S. managing editor of the FT.[3]

Over the next four years, FT.com launched in the U.S.,[7] and U.S. sales tripled to nearly 150,000.[1]

Discussion of "proposed text"
Now I understand that we are dealing with very short sentences here, so the ability to paraphrase the material should not be so difficult. But I'm placed in a bind here if it is the New Yorker source that you insist upon using. Because then the text must be either placed in your own words, or given quotation marks and attributed in the text to that publication's author (example: According to so and so of the New Yorker "This is what happened.") Please advise on how you would like to proceed. Thank you!  spintendo   02:10, 27 June 2018 (UTC)

Again, thank you for your considerable time and attention on this. I have responded to each comment above and would be happy to post a new request if we can come to an agreement on the paraphrasing issue. NinaSpezz (talk) 14:44, 29 June 2018 (UTC)

 * I dont see where the sources are for these statements. In my copying of them I neglected to carry over the references. Go ahead and resubmit a new request with the references added. Claims of employment are best coming from the publication that the subject worked at. The references shouldn't come from an interview or any other source aligned with the subject. I see his employment history as the following:

 * 1) The Herald
 * 2) SMH
 * FT
 * I think mentioning each new publication that the subject joined is germane. By my count that would be three mentions (3). A transfer or a new position within the same company is not really a new job. It's still working for the same employer. As far as the book written by the subject, if it were a book written about modern-day journalism in China, I can see how that would be germane to the article, seeing as how he was a journalist in China. If it's a history book, then I don't think so – unless he was also a historian in China. If it's a historical book about journalism in China, then we'll have to see, maybe that will work. Please advise.  spintendo   22:13, 11 July 2018 (UTC)

Early Career
I work for Rubenstein and on behalf of Robert Thomson I'd like to add the below sentence to the beginning of the "Career" section. I've included four references to demonstrate this is a well-documented fact supported by a variety of sources over time, but I do not expect all four are necessary for inclusion in the Wikipedia article. NinaSpezz (talk) 14:40, 16 July 2018 (UTC)

Thomson began his journalistic career in 1979 as a copyboy at The Herald in Melbourne (now the Herald Sun).

Reply 16-JUL-2018
 spintendo   16:18, 16 July 2018 (UTC)

Sydney Morning Herald & Financial Times
I work for Rubenstein and on behalf of Robert Thomson I'd like to add the below as the second sentence in the "Career" section. I've included several references to demonstrate the positions held at each publication are well-documented facts supported by a variety of sources over time, some of which are already used in the article, but I do not expect all are necessary for inclusion. NinaSpezz (talk) 15:50, 6 August 2018 (UTC)

 * In 1983, he became senior feature writer for The Sydney Morning Herald     and two years later became Beijing correspondent for The Sydney Morning Herald as well as the Financial Times (FT).

✅ used ref 1 &7 (combined) --Danski454 (talk) 16:38, 6 August 2018 (UTC)

Expand career section
I work for Rubenstein and on behalf of Robert Thomson I'd like to add the content below to the "Career" section after the sentence ending in "Financial Times". I've included several references to demonstrate the different positions held at different editions within the Financial Times are well-documented facts supported by a variety of sources over time, some of which are already used in the article, but I do not expect all are necessary for inclusion. NinaSpezz (talk) 20:44, 17 July 2019 (UTC)

 * Thomson then relocated to Toyko to become full-time correspondent for the Financial Times.  Thomson was appointed the Financial Times Foreign News Editor in 1994   and in 1996 became editor of the Financial Times weekend edition.

 * In 1998, Thomson moved to New York to become U.S. managing editor of the Financial Times.

Reply 17-JUL-2019
Regards,  Spintendo  01:54, 18 July 2019 (UTC)
 * 1) This information was previously removed by.
 * 2) The first sentence does not give a date.
 * 3) The second compound sentence's first part Thomson was appointed the Financial Times Foreign News Editor in 1994 needs only the New Yorker reference.
 * 4) The second compound sentence's second part in 1996 became editor of the Financial Times weekend edition is not verified by any of the provided sources.
 * 5) The third sentence In 1998, Thomson moved to New York to become U.S. managing editor of the Financial Times is not verified by the provided sources (i.e., In 1998, Thomson was given the reins of the recently launched US edition, in that "given the reins" does not indicate a position; and the Arango source does not include the quote parameter).

Reply 18-JUL-2019
Based on the feedback above, I have revised this request to add the following content to the "Career" section after the sentence ending in "Financial Times". I am aware this information was previously removed. However, the reason given for the removal was unsourced content.

Please note a year is not provided for the relocation to Tokyo, Japan because the three citations provided that verify a move do not give a date, but do place the move and position as having occurred between other career milestones. NinaSpezz (talk) 13:43, 18 July 2019 (UTC)

 * Thomson then relocated to Toyko to become full-time correspondent for the Financial Times.  Thomson was appointed the Financial Times foreign news editor in 1994 and in 1996 became editor of the Financial Times weekend edition.

 * In 1998, Thomson moved to New York to become U.S. managing editor of the Financial Times.

Reply 18-JUL-2019
Regards, Spintendo  14:39, 18 July 2019 (UTC)
 * The claim regarding relocating to Tokyo was not added, as it conflicts with the prior claim two years later became Beijing correspondent for The Sydney Morning Herald as well as the Financial Times. "As well as the Financial Times" does not clarify if this is the same position at the Financial Times in Tokyo, because the "Beijing" correspondent could very well have worked out of Tokyo — as correspondents are not necessarily attached to the exact city specified — and the claim does not state "as well as for the Financial Times" which would have more definatively placed them in Beijing (i.e., became Beijing correspondent for The Sydney Morning Herald as well as for the Financial Times.) There is no surety without dates.

The Judges Book
I work for Rubenstein and on behalf of Robert Thomson I would like to add just after the sentence that ends with "...later became Beijing correspondent for The Sydney Morning Herald as well as the Financial Times.":

 * While at Sydney Morning Herald, Thomson wrote a series on Australian judges, which was published as a book in 1987, The Judges: A Portrait of an Australian Judiciary.

NinaSpezz (talk) 16:58, 9 June 2020 (UTC)

your edit request has been implemnted Trains2050 (talk) 17:19, 9 June 2020 (UTC)

Tokyo Correspondent + Citation Needed
I work for Rubenstein and on behalf of Robert Thomson I would like to add the following just after the sentence that ends with "...later became Beijing correspondent for The Sydney Morning Herald as well as the Financial Times."

 * Thomson then became a Tokyo correspondent for the Financial Times in 1989.

In addition, I'd like to suggest the following citations to address the "citation needed" tag on the page following "In May 2008 he was appointed managing editor of the Wall Street Journal, having previously been the editor of The Times."

NinaSpezz (talk) 17:49, 16 December 2020 (UTC)
 * I made these changes. I did not use all of the suggested sources. For the WSJ position I added a Bloomberg article. Thanks.DesertDana (talk) 20:17, 12 March 2021 (UTC)

title: Talk:Robert Thomson (executive)